Most Un-reliable car ever?

Currently reading:
Most Un-reliable car ever?

My E Reg 1.5GLX Seat Malaga... spent £1700 keeping it on the road for 16 months. Worst was its need to kill front wheel bearings at a rate of 1 a side every 3K or so (first name terms with tracking operative at local 4 wheel alignment centre), automatic choke that would either not kick in when cold in the morning or fix your idle revs at 2500 rpm after a 18 mile mostly motorway journey home :eek: Handbrake failed and had to drop the fuel tank to replace the cables, interior that would break on contact (perhaps made from reconstituted paella) :rolleyes: Worst was its sudden total loss of grip on wet roads, you turn the steering wheel gently to the left approaching roundabouts at moderate speeds... it slides straight on! Conversation with a friend of a friend with a Prisma (Lancia Delta Saloon I suppose & also based on Fiat Regatta) said his did the same... tyre choice didn't even come into it / seem to make much difference. Fantastic grip in the dry though, strangely enough!

The bit I missed when I bought the car was that it was a Seat UK Demo & me the 5th owner @ 3 years old - A recipie for bad news me thinks :eek:
 
Last edited:
escorts are winning in the unreliability stakes :chin:

did i mention my mates escort? that car had had more than 50x its current value spent on parts for it in the past 3/4 years that thay have owned it (current value £50, waiting on scrappies to pick it up :D)

i think i did mention it....
 
Last edited:
rover sd1 straight 6 2.3/2.6

used to breakdown before it got to the end of the road.
my then pregnant wife would not ride in the car in case it packed up somewhere in the middle of nowhere and she started labour.

had a stupidly complicated miniature carb thingy that was the cold start device nestled between 2 perfectly good SU's so it was always a pig to start.

oil feed to the camshaft had a non return valve that blocked to become a non flow valve and destroyed 2 camshafts.

thrust bearings went and ruined the crankshaft and took out the bearing carrier along the way.

fitted a 2.6 engine from a reputable breaker and it ran fine until the oil pump lost pressure. was totally impossible to remove the pressure relief valve in the pump so it ran with 15psi hot.

vacuum modulator on the auto box that burst its diaphram so the engine (when working~) would suck all the auto tranny fluid into the engine and burn it with huge clouds of white smoke.

central locking that would unlock/lock/unlock/lock etc. etc. as you walked away from the car so you never knew if it was actually locked or not until you returned to the car.

window motors that would stop for no reason.

instruments that randomly worked.

jacking points on the bumper corners that coudn't take the weight of the car.

boy that was a fun 6 months, best car i've ever had for the learning experience.
 
It's gotta be the Austin all agro (Allegro) lol. Pieces of junk that never worked!

MSH

I actually liked the allegro. I found it a doddle to work on - bought one dirt cheap, pulled the lump & had it sat under a tarp for a month while I reconditioned it, cleaned the ignition sytem, put it all back together & it really shifted.
Trouble with a thread like this is that people's experiences can be marred so easily and yet you can buy two identical cars, treat them the same & one can be nothing but trouble.
Me & dad bought identical cars together (got a really nice discount for the double). Both cars always garaged, both cars doing similar mileage in similar weather.
Mine refused to start when hot (so a break on a motorway journey had to be taken with the bonnet up & long enough to let the engine cool or sit with the engine ticking over), had it back to the garage on a monthly basis for that one. At 1 yr old, the dash cracked & all the lights shorted & lit together, got a new one under warranty (just). At 3 yrs old, the inner CV boots split (couldn't be the easy to replace outers could it?). At 6 yrs old, had to have both cills replaced. At 8 yrs old, had to have the boot replaced, at 10 yrs old, I replaced the head gasket. At some point I'd also replaced the alternator, starter motor, battery, exhaust and every tyre was renewed at least twice.
Interestingly, Dad's had about two thousand more on the clock by this time - and never a moment's trouble and still with every original component.
 
It's gotta be the Austin all agro (Allegro) lol. Pieces of junk that never worked!

MSH

Did you own one? You're probably actually too young to even remember them properly? My mother bought one (Allegro 3) new in 1982 it remained in the family in daily use for 18 years handed down to both my brother and then sister until my sister could afford to buy a better car. In that time it never broke down and had not a single bit of rust. It was finally written off by an insurance company in 2001 when someone drove into it.

Sure not a fantastic car when compared with modern fare but certainly not as awful as people would have you believe.

For me the worst car I've owned was a Citroen Xsara, my dad got one as a company and equally had problems for 3 years.
 
Last edited:
Worst car was my mate's da's Renault 9 Biarritz. It broke down everywhere...
Filled it to the neck with petrol once and just a couple of miles later - Petrol warning, tank bust... :bang:
Without trying to make (too) light of the problems at the time, I would think a mobile petrol bomb wouldn't have made him too popular with either the neighbours or the R.U.C.
 
im now going to nominate my mates (old) clio 1.9D :)

he got it to replace the escort that he had before, what a mistake!

the immobiliser seems bent on commiting suicide, its had a brand new code PCB put in, it lasted 3 days :bang:

i hope he scraps it, its truely the worst car i have ever been in, the discs are warped, its very slow, and the sunroof piddles water all over you:(
 
im now going to nominate my mates (old) clio 1.9D :)

he got it to replace the escort that he had before, what a mistake!

the immobiliser seems bent on commiting suicide, its had a brand new code PCB put in, it lasted 3 days :bang:

i hope he scraps it, its truely the worst car i have ever been in, the discs are warped, its very slow, and the sunroof piddles water all over you:(

The one we saved with the stilo :p I think he was most dis-pleased at being saved by a fiat :D

Jordan
 
im now going to nominate my mates (old) clio 1.9D :)

he got it to replace the escort that he had before, what a mistake!

the immobiliser seems bent on commiting suicide, its had a brand new code PCB put in, it lasted 3 days :bang:

i hope he scraps it, its truely the worst car i have ever been in, the discs are warped, its very slow, and the sunroof piddles water all over you:(

Well it is French.....
 
Bizarrely, even taking into account my parents' cars as well as mine and She Who Must Be Obeyed's we haven't really had a bad one. Here follows a fairly extensive list.
1959-Isetta bubble car. Only one memory, (I was only 2 at the time) going up a single track road on the moors above Bury. Found out the road was closed due to lambing when we got to the closed gate. Parents got out of the front of the car, and I do mean the front, picked it up bodily and turned it through 180 degrees, got back in and drove off. Makes even a Panda seem unwieldy. After minor lower body damage, the repaired section was painted a contrasting darker blue, so was born the first custom Bubble Car in Manchester. My Dad a trendsetter Woo Hoo!
1960-Austin A30. Can't remember anything about that. According to the Old Man there weren't any problems with it.
1962-Austin A40. Certainly remember the backs of my legs when wearing short trousers sticking to the seat in summer. Please can I have long trousers Mum? It needed a clutch after about 27,000 miles which according to Dad was a good mileage. He hired a Ford Consul for the day while it was being repaired. This had "interesting" vacuum operated wipers. They went so fast at high speed it looked like they would fly off, but at slow speed they almost stopped.
1966-Austin 1100. Again, fairly unremarkable, except that it had as much room inside as the Consul, a much bigger car. Never broke down.
1969-Vauxhall Cresta. (2 years old) I think he had a touch of brain fade here as this was a bit of a monster. Even able (in an emergency) to carry two 13 year olds in the boot (stupid, I know but this was the 60's man.)
1969-Vauxhall Viva. We became a 2 car family. Middle classes here we come.
Again, no problems but batteries, tyres, clutches and brake linings were doing well if they lasted much more than 25K. The first car I ever drove in '74.
1971-Vauxhall VX 4/90 replaced the Cresta. First car with a rev counter, also had Rostyle wheels and 4 "bucket seats" and, best of all, overdrive on 3rd and 4th gear, making it a 6 speed box.
1972-Vauxhall Ventora replaced the VX 4/90. I think he was going power mad as it had the same 3.3 litre 6 engine but in a smaller body.
1974-Vauxhall Viva replaced the previous HB
1975-Austin 1800. A return to family sanity with a more economical car.
1978-Vauxhall Chevette replaced the Viva. Luckily, my Mother didn't like it so I bought it for a song.
1979-Mini 1000. This replaced the Chevette I "stole" from her. When she got it on the drive, my Dad checked it over & found a spare wheel well full of water with a mouldy bacon (possibly) sandwich floating in it. Good start eh?
1980-Renault 18. Replaced the 1800. He was never that happy with the car as it had a number of rattles and electrical niggles.
1981-Vauxhall Chevette 2300HS. Twin Weber 45's with inlet manifold, big valve conversion, fast road cams, free flow exhaust manifold and big bore exhaust. Never RR tested but estimated 190 bhp. Had the same main fault as the earlier 1.3; a rust trap behind the headlights. Eventually written off by a reversing truck in a car park. The insurance company valued it as a standard car.
1985-Series of company cars.
1987-Metro 1000/1300s Instructor for BSM. Gutless, heavy steering, binding brakes, heavy or slipping clutches, sensitive tracking, windows that stuck half way up and so on ad nauseum.
1989-Renault replaced by a Nissan Sunny. Predictably faultless. This car was stolen during a burglary and was driven around the local area for 2 years before one of those Coppers who has nothing better to do with their time than persecute innocent motorists, stopped the driver and found his finger prints matched those found at the house.
1989-Uno 60DS. Threw my dummy out of the pram and left BSM to go on my own. They bribed me to come back so I ended up using the revised Rover 100which I found surprisingly good. Good K class engines, gearboxes from VW and Honda. Handled better and was reliable.
1991-Nissan Sunny 1.6 to replace the stolen one.
1991-Dummy out again. Carried on with the Uno working on my own. 130,000 miles with only one clutch change and 2 brake re-lines. Only fault was a rebuilt diesel pump needed because I let it run out of fuel 3 times.
1994-Rover 214 SLi. This car gave pretty much reliable service although to be fair, it has only done 19K at the time of writing and is about to be P/Xd.
1996-Vauxhall Astra 1.6. Used for Instructor training. Reliable but sluggish with a geanerally low rent feel.
1997-Rover 200 diesel. Replaced the Astra. This too was reliable but small for its price. Not really much bigger that the Uno. Dreadful turbo lag.
1998-Rover 114. AA Driving School. Much better, in fact, even today it's probably the most fun for the money I've ever had in a car (with my clothes on)
1998-Punto 60S Bought by my Mother.
1999-Fiesta Ghia. Handlling not quite as good as the 100, but otherwise a cracking little car.
2001-Focus 1.6 Ghia. These replaced the Fiestas. I had 6 of these cars and although we only kept them for 18K, none of them needed any oil or anything but regular servicing.
2002-Punto 60S bought by She Who Must Be Obeyed. 4 years old with 9K on the clock. This car blew it's head gasket in 2006.
2002-Punto 60SX bought buy my Mum to replace the one above that came into our hands.
2005-Panda MJT. 30K so far. Needed pads and discs when pads wore out without warning. Otherwise, no faults.
2006-Stilo Active. '05 reg. 1K on the clock. Replaced Punto 60S with blown head gasket. Now just coming up on 20K.
2008-Very few of the cars that have passed through our family have cause any real problems. The Metros were very badly put together without a doubt. The Renault never really inspired confidence and, almost forgot, there was a VW Jetta in there somewhere that was so badly finished that (although reliable) had a hole where the glove box lid should have been, had brittle black plastic all over the dash which creaked over every bump and an engine that always sounded as if the tappets needed adjusting. The Head Gasket problem on the Punto 60S was a known quantity, although not to us and the 60SX Mk II that replaced didn't have that problem. Most of these cars didn't give anywhere near the problems so many seem to have had.
 
I must have had about 30 cars since passing my test in 1990 and thankfully haven't had any real horrors!! My first car was a 1977 Renault 6TL with a habit of blowing head gaskets, a (spanky new) 1995 Golf 1.9D was let down by terrible dealer service and one of the 5 VW T3 campers which i've owned got through 3 turbos in a year!! but other than that they have all been ok.

JON
 
Any thing french especialy a Renault 4
! had one with string seats if you drove it for over an hr you lost the feeling in your legs
it had a bannana gear stick with only 3 forward gears that the linkage made imposible to tell what gear you had selected
it once tipped over as I turned a corner ..... the rear radial arm collapsed saving me from rolling down a hill thank god
a rubgy team danced on its roof while drunk (not the cars fault that ) but it did get rather squashed
it.s exhaust dropped off
and it finaly popped a con rod through the block
I pushed it to a scrap yard and quietly left lol
ah happy memorys of living in france
it did get me to sete once that was a fantastic week end .....lol when i got to feel my legs again
 
well i have had alot of bad expierences with a Peugeot 106. Im not going into detail.

I also believe that Rovers are unreliable as have seen and heard about alot of them breaking down.


So im going to have to say that Rovers are the most unreliable
 
I do 25000 miles a year and can honestly say I see very few FIATS broken down, maybe I note VW more as the ad used to say "if only everything in life was as reliable as a VW". Not many Jap cars seem to litter the hard shoulders but French cars abound. Vauxhalls dont seem to be the best in terms of breakdowns, I see a wide variety of those particularly Vectras. I guess the quality of servicing has a lot to do with most breakdowns with any make, none are especially worse than others these days IMO.
 
Back
Top