Ah, the great "quality" after market air filter question. Having been interested in motor sport all my life and appreciating a "nice sounding" motor, I've looked at these, often very expensive, alternative filters many times. Here's a very interesting video which largely sums up what I've found - pay attention to the bit about "oiled" elements by the way:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PAIxeQUSg-Q
My conclusion? Well, all the cars I look after are running around with paper filters and standard inlet setups. I really do believe it's only worth spending the cash if you are very considerably modifying your engine so it gulps a lot more air than the standard setup - and then, to gain maximum, benefit you really must remap on a dyno because the airflow is going to be very different to that with the standard inlet tract in place. On the other hand, by all means do it if you just want the "bling" and noise but bear in mind the warning about MAF sensors with oiled elements. Also bear in mind that fitting a very free flowing filter and inlet piping may "mess with" calibration to such an extent that you could actually suffer a slight reduction in power - you probably won't detect this on the road, through the seat of your pants, and the gutsy sounding intake noises will tend to decieve you too!