Tuning much cheaper SS and MS manifolds (16v)

Currently reading:
Tuning much cheaper SS and MS manifolds (16v)

I'd have had enough personally...I'd have returned it and saved for a SS

Ive not been in any rush to get my car all sorted, though mod nats is looming and id like it finished by then, if not then, will definatley be at Stanford. The only reason its taken so long is because i told him i wasnt in any rush. If id have rung him every day and asked him about the progress, it would be done in no time.
My cars currently garaged and i've only been driving it on the odd weekend in sunny weather recently. So not caused me any hassle tbh.
Sure it might costed me time and postage to send it back but he said he'll reimburse my extra costs.

See in normal cases i would do that, but i think JA is almost half the price of SS
£235 for stainless mani inlcuding postage from JA.
£365 for SS from Gazzella (not including any p&p costs).
Saving £130.

I thought id be the first, as i knew i wouldnt be in any rush. Plus with me being the guinea pig any other members that order after me will have a trouble free time buying one and know itll fit.
He had my first one made and shipped out to me in no time. Plus as ming says the price compared to the SS mani, i dont mind waiting. (Whitz did say in post one they could do 48h postage even)
What are the average waiting times like with Gazzella? (thats an honest question by the way)
 
Last edited:
Average time currently is entirely dependant on his suppliers and shipping.

So... 2 months? :D

I was lucky and got my SS mani in about a month and also managed to find him some extra business with strong flex (never found out how he got on with them though (n)).

Thanks

X
 
I went to JA on the 7th of May with Todger. Took Todger's SS mani with us for a comparision. They set it all up on the jig and set about creating one that was similiar.
All we had to do was wait around in the front of the shop for five hours while they made it.

Unsure about clearance around the sump in the shop. Thought it might be quite tight, only one way we could be sure though. So took it back home and tried it on the engine.

IMG_04562.JPG


IMG_04554.JPG


IMG_04531.JPG


IMG_04521.JPG



Looked pretty good. Only three issues. The top flange; wouldnt be possible to put a standard size nut too tighten it to the head.
The exhaust was rather close too the holes on the flange. Would have been possible too use a spring washer and a smaller nut. However the second problem was far worse. The bottom pipe underneath the sump was no where near parallel to the ground. No piece of flexi-pipe would have been able to correct it.
Also the exhaust is too long still, it would have hit the slam pannel/rad.

Todger's SS mani shows this in Chalky.

IMG_06011.JPG


IMG_06031.JPG


JA mani was about 6.5" from the head. While the SS is just about 5.25"
IMG_0609.JPG




Due to work commitments and family stuff, I took a break from working on the car but then decided it was time to get it all sorted.
So two days ago i went back to JA, taking the engine on the stand with me. Meaning they would be able to use it as a jig.
IMG_06121.JPG


Spoke to John about it and said as he had already created the mani I ordered (Standard 16v one) but as i needed a custom bespoke mani he would have too charge me half price to create another. So I left the engine with him for a day whilst I wondered what to do next.

Had a chat about it and decided it wasnt worth it. So I went back (another 80 mile round trip) and wanted my money back and no manifold. As the manifold he made for me was a bespoke mani, he told me i could either keep it (though reselling it would be impossible, due to issues i mentioned earlier) or I can have half my money back. (doesnt give full refunds for custom parts).
I wouldnt be given all my money back basically, no matter what i did.

So i asked for my second, standard punto manifold back. I had already bought it and though it wont fit a cento, I still owned it.

Before I left he offered me a deal however; he would create me another two piece manifold on the car. As in, i would get the car too Walsall on a trailer with the new engine in. He would then create a manifold on the car itself. No charge for the mani, just the full exhaust system

I tried to explain to him how tight the Cento bays are though, as even creating it on the car would be near impossible. Explaing how to get these engines in the car and showing him pictures of Todger's SS mani.

So basically, I am now (probably) going to get a SS mani.

This is not me trying to slate JA exhausts in any way. John was always helpful and tried to create a soloution for me.

Just I now have a large paperweight sat in my garage for sale...

Pirus
 
why can't they copy the SS one ?

IF you want a cheap solution, mk1 sporting exhaust mani and down pipe is almost perfect on the cento with a small piece with 2 sleeves to make mate it on to the orginial cento system!

Thanks
Ming
 
He won't copy the supersprint as he simpl doesn't have the means to do it.

Supersprint tubing is slotted into the flange then internally welded, whereas JA can only but weld the tubing to the flange.

All of the bends are mandrel for the supersprint, and JA charges extra for mandrel bends.

His welding isn't as seamless as the SS's are, and penetration is all over the place.

JA does his best for in house made items, whereas SS makes all of there stuff in a workshop/factory. SS have a quality control for their items, if it doesn't meet a certain regualtion, it doesn't get shipped. JA doesn't have that kind of regulation, let alone testing.

I'm not slating him, but if i'm honest.... I won't be going there for my new exhaust. I will save my money and go to RS fabrications.

Thanks

X
 
after making my manifold i know how ja feels. it really is tight. and supersprint manifolds as said are welded internally and obviously have the tools and proper jigs (welding looks like its done robotic)

they made the custom exhaust system for mine and did a brilliant job... it was the first cento he did and it took them all day. I dont know what quotes hes given for others for a system but he said he would never do another cento as its to tight. my mate asked and he was quoted over twice what I paid
 
Can't really compare factory against a custome man made system! Factorys wins all day long in quality :)

But dam, i really hoped they could of made one that fits the cinq!

Did he say he can't copy or the SS or we are just assuming?

Thanks
Ming
 
Also to be fair ~ yes the manifold he got wasn't fit for purpose, but did he get the car and engine fitted to make the manifold?

We should really support this rather than put him down ..... as he is possibly the only one that is willing to make a mani that fits at half the SS price!

Ming
 
...he said he would never do another cento as its to tight. my mate asked and he was quoted over twice what I paid

Yeh he said the same thing to me about my mani. He said it probably would cost about half as much on top of £235. So around £360. Same price as a SS mani.

Also to be fair ~ yes the manifold he got wasn't fit for purpose, but did he get the car and engine fitted to make the manifold?

No he only had the engine for one day to start measuring for the new mani. However after telling me I would be charged for another to be made, I just dont have the money.
On my original receipt I placed the order for this mani on 11/2/2011.
John acknowledged how patient ive been and thats why he offered to build me another mani for free on the car. Just need to put the engine in and get the car on a trailer over to Walsall.

RS fabs are absolutely awesome at what they do, so expensive tho!
Gonna give them a ring in a day or two and get a quote for full system (not including a mani).


Pirus
 
RS did a full system for ghostwkd on his highboost cinq, theyre expensive i warn you that :p, but their welding is so good all the parts looked factory probably even better than supersprint quality!
 
He won't copy the supersprint as he simpl doesn't have the means to do it.

Supersprint tubing is slotted into the flange then internally welded, whereas JA can only but weld the tubing to the flange.

All of the bends are mandrel for the supersprint, and JA charges extra for mandrel bends.

His welding isn't as seamless as the SS's are, and penetration is all over the place.

JA does his best for in house made items, whereas SS makes all of there stuff in a workshop/factory. SS have a quality control for their items, if it doesn't meet a certain regualtion, it doesn't get shipped. JA doesn't have that kind of regulation, let alone testing.

I'm not slating him, but if i'm honest.... I won't be going there for my new exhaust. I will save my money and go to RS fabrications.

Thanks

X

Quite surprised they're not mandrel bent.. bent any other way they collapse inside iirc?

As has been said, the suppersprint manifold *just* fits - if he hasn't got the kit to copy the bends of the SS manifold, then he can't make a suitable manifold and that's that.

Need to bear in mind that it isn't "half the price" of a supersprint manifold either.

didnt arc have a good pic of the clearance of the supersprint manifold to the bulk head? may be worth a search. if i can remember...its not alot(n) id put money the new'n not fitting

I have some of the 8v;





and this is the SS on my 1.4 16v;







 
Last edited:
Back
Top