Just been reflecting on front wheel bearings and my experiences with them. My recollection is that modern bearings seem to be rather more long lasting than these earlier designs. Of course materials and tolerances will have improved considerably but it occurs to me that most of those earlier designs included a "wild card" that the bearing manufacturers had no control over. These earlier set ups consisted of two separate bearing assemblies (each with an inner race, bearings - ball or taper roller - and an outer race) with a spacer between the inner races or extended "shoulders" on the inner races, like these Allegro ones:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/i/3711136039...1w73LqB8F6EBDQ7MHLyAl7XaLwz64TSAaAupbEALw_wcB
which were mounted in a hub which was machined to the vehicle manufacturer's spec. ie not the bearing manufacturer. So the distance between the outer races was set by the way the hub had been machined but the inner races were kept apart by the spacer provided in the bearing kit so manufactured by the bearing manufacturer. Almost bound to go wrong wasn't it? Then they came out with one piece bearings, Like this Maxi one:
https://www.bearings-online.co.uk/i...c-d7cs8cVljPsPtIAhVbtvgY6511R8psaAhJSEALw_wcB
which seems to be the norm now, where both races share a common outer. So now the whole assembly is under the bearing manufacturers control. Technically a much better solution.
However, Whereas the old design was a relatively easy (for someone with a bit of know how) "DIY in the drive job" with a brass punch, you now have this very wide outer one piece race to remove. Good luck moving that with a punch! I remember the first Maxi one I ever did and having quite a struggle with it despite having access to the shop press.
https://www.ebay.co.uk/i/3711136039...1w73LqB8F6EBDQ7MHLyAl7XaLwz64TSAaAupbEALw_wcB
which were mounted in a hub which was machined to the vehicle manufacturer's spec. ie not the bearing manufacturer. So the distance between the outer races was set by the way the hub had been machined but the inner races were kept apart by the spacer provided in the bearing kit so manufactured by the bearing manufacturer. Almost bound to go wrong wasn't it? Then they came out with one piece bearings, Like this Maxi one:
https://www.bearings-online.co.uk/i...c-d7cs8cVljPsPtIAhVbtvgY6511R8psaAhJSEALw_wcB
which seems to be the norm now, where both races share a common outer. So now the whole assembly is under the bearing manufacturers control. Technically a much better solution.
However, Whereas the old design was a relatively easy (for someone with a bit of know how) "DIY in the drive job" with a brass punch, you now have this very wide outer one piece race to remove. Good luck moving that with a punch! I remember the first Maxi one I ever did and having quite a struggle with it despite having access to the shop press.
This post contains affiliate links which may earn a commission at no additional cost to you.