Well Ffoxy I think it has to be said that you are lending credence to my earlier statement regarding owners who wont say or hear anything negative about the car and at the same time extoll its virtues at any given opportunity despite its problematic reputation.
I can accept that you think its value for money, that you like the car and that you want to tell others that you like the car, so do many other GP owners but just because you think that way is it right to assume others will? Personally I would be saying, here are my pros, here are the cons....they are all based on my experiences of owning a GP........go make your own mind up. What I find particularly amusing is the fact power and top speed are always the first things mentioned...never the fact it has a 5-star N-cap rating.
Without going into detail I bought a GP about 6 months ago, the problems started before I had even driven it home and it rapidly became a nightmare. It took the intervention of a solicitor to get the problems sorted and I have to say in 25yrs of car ownership I have never had so many issues with any car I have owned, be it used or brand new. I still dont know who is to blame, Fiat for making the car, the dealer for selling it and providing poor support or myself for expecting too much from both Fiat and my dealer.
As it stands and in fairness the problems have all been sorted, the car is now doing what I expected it to do when I first bought it and my negativity towards it, Fiat, and my dealer is fading although as I hope you understand, it will never completely dissapear.
You could say you I could have bought a fiesta/corsa/clio/207 etc etc and had the same problems, true I could have, but the fact remains, I didnt.
Regarding your comments about "plush" and "comfortable" cars.....I am going to Asda in the morning and I intend to take the GP..... because its good at that sort of thing. Next week I have a 650 mile round journy to make, I will be taking my company (and so far faultless after 70k miles) x-type.....because its good at that sort of thing.........choosing and owning cars is horses for courses, you buy what what suits your needs and that you hope meets your requirements
PS I understand and wont be surprized if you, or anyone else for that matter says "I would take the GP"