Technical Euro 4 1.2 thermostat change

Currently reading:
Technical Euro 4 1.2 thermostat change

jrkitching

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Mar 1, 2010
Messages
11,370
Points
2,925
Location
Dorset
Since the weather turned colder this year, I'd noticed that the Panda has been a bit slower to reach operating temperature, and that the temperature gauge was settling just a bit lower than was usual. We're not talking much here, perhaps a couple of times the thickness of the needle, but fuel economy was also down by at least 10% on my last long run, so this definitely warranted a closer look.

My first thought was that either the bypass on the thermostat housing, or the thermostat itself, was sticking slightly open, so I pulled out the thermostat for a closer look. I couldn't see anything wrong with it, and it also passed a hot water test, but having got this far, I thought I'd replace it anyway as they're cheap as chips (a whopping £7.79 from ECP).

Happily all is well again. The needle is now rock steady and exactly on the centre mark on the temperature gauge; initial indications are that fuel economy is also back to normal.

Clearly the old thermostat must have been letting colder water through, so if you do notice your Panda is running a bit colder than usual, be aware that these thermostats can fail and still appear on inspection to be working.

Replacing the thermostat is straightforward enough, but you'll need to remove a few ancillaries; what exactly probably depends on the specific model. On the Euro4 engine, both the coil packs and the engine ECU are directly in the way; the former are bolted to a carrier on the cylinder head (3 bolts) and the latter just sits loose in a carrier bolted to the battery tray (2 bolts and an earthing strap). If you're careful, you can unbolt this lot, swing the packs and ECU out of the way without disturbing any wiring, and remove the battery tray.

It also helps to remove the airbox; not strictly necessary, but it's only a couple of bolts and takes just a minute or two.

The easiest way to deal with the coolant is to syphon it out; that way, you've only the single coolant hose connection on the thermostat housing itself to deal with, and you can break that after the coolant is out, so no mess anywhere :). If the coolant is uncontaminated and within its service life, you can then just put it back at the end of the job. Expect to get about 3 - 3.5 litres out. Getting it back in might be harder than getting it out; the Panda is notoriously awkward to get coolant in. It helps to completely remove (don't just loosen it) the bleed on the heater hose before you start; this bleed is above the top of the header tank, so you won't lose any coolant (unless you forget to replace it before starting the engine :bang:). The system self-bleeds after a few hot/cold cycles, so keep a close eye on the level during this period, as it will likely drop a little.

The car is now almost 10 yrs old and has done about 95k; this is only the second non-routine parts replacement (the first was the battery earlier this year), so it's proving to be a reliable car.

That said, since all the suspension and other commonly wearing stuff is still original, I may have to make a decision next year about whether to give it an extra heavy overhaul, or to replace it.
 
Last edited:
I've just done this today, and found the above very helpful, so thanks!
I'll be uploading some pictures later for anyone else who and might find them useful
 
Step 1: Locate thermostat and remove battery and battery mount.
Sockets needed 10mm and 13mm, plus a 10mm spanner for the earth wire on the ECU (not enough clearance for a socket and wrench).
Pitfalls: Several annoyingly fiddly plastic clips to wiring/hose bundles on the bottom of the battery mount - find someone with small hands to undo them. Plus one cable tie in one at the front that needs cutting. Make sure you've got all of them undone before you lift it out
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200912_193347807~3.jpg
    IMG_20200912_193347807~3.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 68
  • IMG_20200912_164436862~2.jpg
    IMG_20200912_164436862~2.jpg
    1.6 MB · Views: 63
Step 2: Give up on getting the stupid hose clip undone in place and unbolt the thermostat (2 10mm bolts) to get easier access. Discover you've not drained all the coolant ?
Step 3: Injure your helpful family member trying to undo the stupid clip, trying a variety of bending back the clips, attacking with pliers and swearing
10mm socket, medium socket extension, 25-35mm jubilee clip (because I refuse to believe you can get the original one off in a state to reuse)
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200912_172537208~2.jpg
    IMG_20200912_172537208~2.jpg
    1.6 MB · Views: 55
  • IMG_20200912_172550726~2.jpg
    IMG_20200912_172550726~2.jpg
    1.4 MB · Views: 56
  • IMG_20200912_173431010.jpg
    IMG_20200912_173431010.jpg
    2.8 MB · Views: 59
  • IMG_20200912_173914936.jpg
    IMG_20200912_173914936.jpg
    2.5 MB · Views: 56
  • IMG_20200912_173919206.jpg
    IMG_20200912_173919206.jpg
    2.6 MB · Views: 55
Step 4: Try (mostly fail) to clean the gasket crap off before refitting everything
 
The angle is a pain though! You think you've got it all, then stick your phone down there to take a photo to check and there's another bit on the corner!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200912_175823614.jpg
    IMG_20200912_175823614.jpg
    5.4 MB · Views: 49
The angle is a pain though! You think you've got it all, then stick your phone down there to take a photo to check and there's another bit on the corner!


Undo the plate that holds the coil packs and swing the whole lot out of the way. You don't have to disconnect any of the wires

Its then all there easy and visable instead of work at an angle under them

I not a big believer in undoing more than you have to. But its only a few bolts although one isn't obvious


But in this case it cuts the job in half plus you do a better job. Same with the rear hubs when changing the shoes it just isn't worth working around it.


Apart from these two cases i always undo the very minimum
 
And now I've snapped one of the negative wires on the battery clamp putting everything back ?*♀️
I knew this job had gone too smoothly!
 

Attachments

  • IMG_20200913_130108580.jpg
    IMG_20200913_130108580.jpg
    3 MB · Views: 39
Could be worse it could have broken while out on the road

At least its an easy repair.


I doubt you will have a large crimp tool or connector. You can strip the end and pinch it under one of the other temporarily At least you will be back running in a couple of minutes


For convince its probably worth talking to the mechanics at a local garage they will probably pop a new one one free of charge

Other options would be either buy a new crimp and crush it on with pliers or get a replacement cable from the breakers. You could buy a crimper if you do a lot of repairs. I use mine rarely though. Its possible to flame solder the parts. I wouldn't recommend this as the wires go brittle and may fail down the line
 
Maybe just my bad luck but my perception is that the wee FIRE engines have a liking for a new thermostat from time to time. We've had Pandas in the family for many years. First one was my daughter's 750cc, think it had just one. Then we replaced it with a 999cc, it had one too. Then Felicity (the bluey purple one in my avatar) who was part of the family for over 20 years. She had no less than 4! The latest "family member" is Becky, our Dynamic Eco 1.2 who seems to be joining the trend as her temperature gauge seldom climbs above the quarter mark unless in heavy traffic. I'll be putting a new one in her soon so thanks for this thread, very timely!
 
Maybe just my bad luck but my perception is that the wee FIRE engines have a liking for a new thermostat from time to time. We've had Pandas in the family for many years. First one was my daughter's 750cc, think it had just one. Then we replaced it with a 999cc, it had one too. Then Felicity (the bluey purple one in my avatar) who was part of the family for over 20 years. She had no less than 4! The latest "family member" is Becky, our Dynamic Eco 1.2 who seems to be joining the trend as her temperature gauge seldom climbs above the quarter mark unless in heavy traffic. I'll be putting a new one in her soon so thanks for this thread, very timely!

Its not the thermostat itself that fails


There's a internal rubber sealing washer that perishes away. leaving a gap. So it can never fully close


They all fail after around 10 years
 
Its not the thermostat itself that fails


There's a internal rubber sealing washer that perishes away. leaving a gap. So it can never fully close


They all fail after around 10 years

Aaaah! another light bulb moment! I've long been puzzled about why these seem to need regularly replacing when a cursory examination seems to show nothing wrong. I'll be having a good close look at Becky's old one when I do the job. Thanks very much Koalar.
 
If you mean the so-called QD hose clips on the radiator, I learned the hard way with them on a Punto. Now, I just remove the single-use hose clip and use worm drive clip for refitting the hose.The QD stays untouched on the rad.
 
Step 2: Give up on getting the stupid hose clip undone in place and unbolt the thermostat (2 10mm bolts) to get easier access. Discover you've not drained all the coolant ?
Step 3: Injure your helpful family member trying to undo the stupid clip, trying a variety of bending back the clips, attacking with pliers and swearing
10mm socket, medium socket extension, 25-35mm jubilee clip (because I refuse to believe you can get the original one off in a state to reuse)
Those pics of the stat are the same as the stat on my car. Does the stat pull out of the housing or does it come as a complete unit.
Thanks.
 
Those pics of the stat are the same as the stat on my car. Does the stat pull out of the housing or does it come as a complete unit.
Thanks.
Comes as a complete unit, or at least every one I've done has? :https://www.shop4parts.co.uk/?name=store&op=Product&ProdID=470
The Original Birth comes with a gasket in the box as does other aftermarket makes I've bought. The genuine FCA does not so you have to buy the gasket separately.

Not a bad job to do. I did our 2010 1.2 Dynamic Eco without removing the battery but you need a 1/4 drive socket set to get into the wee fixings for the coils so you can move them out of the way. I don't think there's much in it as to whether you decide to remove the battery or not and, on mine anyway, the body module ECU "remembers" the radio code so when you reconnect the battery the radio still works.

PS. I agree with the comments about the hose quick connectors. Leave them alone. The original hose clips are a small aggravation to deal with - just destroy them and pull the hose off in the time honoured way then use worm drive clips (jubilee type) to reassemble - If you break one of the quick connectors it's a real b****r.
 
Last edited:
The (so called) single use clips "can" be reused. But, for what it costs for a worm drive clip, there is simply no point. Screwdriver under the OEM clip overlap and it should ping off. Failing that, some hefty side or end cutters will chop the crimped section.

When I did ours, I took out the battery tray - it's just three bolts plus battery. I was glad I did because access is so much easier. AND - the OEM paint is black but not much else. A good clean and repaint is well worth doing. The middle bolt is a bit awkward. Grease on the socket (to hold the belt) or a magnet gets the job done.

While in there check, the clutch slave cylinder bleed nipple - they rust and seize up. You could also consider bleeding the clutch hydraulics as its 10x easier with the battery case out of the way. You dont even need any help. Syringe old fluid out of clutch reservoir. Fill with new. Open bleed nipple. Push the pedal down - it will stay down. Close the bleed nipple. Slowly pull the pedal up and repeat. Keep the fluid above 50% and repeat 10 x. Job done.
 
Back
Top