Technical Windscreen replacement - options?

[AAB1992]

Just a quick update.



I wasn't able to source (within a reasonable distance) an original OEM used Pilkington glass (which would have been my preferred option).



I contacted 5 companies around Bradford/Halifax and surprisingly most would fit a used screen for between £60-95. Fiat wanted £438.19 for a genuine screen (and that’s not for the heated windscreen version!). New aftermarket ones were between £210-220 fitted which is reasonable I guess. Apparently there is no real choice with aftermarket, you get what your given and what’s in stock with the supplier(s).



I just booked the car in with the company closest. Ideally I wanted a screen that was produced from reputable company but they couldn’t specify. I believe they use Charles Pugh Glass LTD. It was a quick job, in and out within 45 mins. I was impressed with the service, less so with screen itself. It’s made from a company called Lamishield® (never heard of them!?).



You can tell it’s an inferior product from the way it’s cut, bonded together and the scuttle panel that clips into the rubber strip at the bottom of the windscreen doesn’t fit well at all. Its budget glass at best.



I think with any replacement glass, it’s a Russian roulette, I’m not sure if the bigger players use more well-known brands, but I suspect not in this era of cost cutting. I just hope the glass stands up well to a couple more years of driving and then the car will be past its sell-by-date anyway.

 

[jrkitching]

Thanks for the update; sorry that you didn't quite get the end result you were hoping for.

But even if you'd paid £438.19 to Fiat (did that include fitting?), it could have been hit by a stone driving home.

And I'll bet most OEM screens from breakers have a fair amount of accumulated wear & tear, and possibly removal rash.

At least you've got a serviceable screen that'll pass an MOT and, fingers crossed, see out the remaining time you have with the car.

It’s made from a company called Lamishield® (never heard of them!?)

Sounds like a veterinary medication for a juvenile ovine.

 

[Marcus Daly]

I think with any replacement glass, it’s a Russian roulette, I’m not sure if the bigger players use more well-known brands, but I suspect not in this era of cost cutting. I just hope the glass stands up well to a couple more years of driving and then the car will be past its sell-by-date anyway.

I got a stonechip within a few weeks of taking delivery of my Panda. Autoglass came to repair it, but in so doing turned the chip into a crack. I waited ages for them to fit a replacement (at their cost), but when they did it was Fiat-stickered OEM (Pilkington), I presume because it's heated and there's no aftermarket version.

 

[porta]

I’ve put through three windscreen ‘claims’ on cars past and present with no detrimental effect to my premiums. But then my insurance specifically notes that this is the case, not all do, with a £25 excess on window cover.
In my past I’ve fitted screens, including bonded ones but, since leaving the trade, I have only done bonded rear screens and side glasses myself. I don’t trust many of the cheap kits and always buy decent gear and have never fitted a second hand one.
Delamination of used screens is common as is scratching/removing/damaging the ‘blacked out’ portion of the screen surround. This band is there to stop UV degeneration of the bonding medium

 

[porta]

Just a quick update.



I wasn't able to source (within a reasonable distance) an original OEM used Pilkington glass (which would have been my preferred option).



I contacted 5 companies around Bradford/Halifax and surprisingly most would fit a used screen for between £60-95. Fiat wanted £438.19 for a genuine screen (and that’s not for the heated windscreen version!). New aftermarket ones were between £210-220 fitted which is reasonable I guess. Apparently there is no real choice with aftermarket, you get what your given and what’s in stock with the supplier(s).



I just booked the car in with the company closest. Ideally I wanted a screen that was produced from reputable company but they couldn’t specify. I believe they use Charles Pugh Glass LTD. It was a quick job, in and out within 45 mins. I was impressed with the service, less so with screen itself. It’s made from a company called Lamishield® (never heard of them!?).



You can tell it’s an inferior product from the way it’s cut, bonded together and the scuttle panel that clips into the rubber strip at the bottom of the windscreen doesn’t fit well at all. Its budget glass at best.



I think with any replacement glass, it’s a Russian roulette, I’m not sure if the bigger players use more well-known brands, but I suspect not in this era of cost cutting. I just hope the glass stands up well to a couple more years of driving and then the car will be past its sell-by-date anyway.

Stoneacre cleckheaton and army’ clarkes Huddersfield or Leeds, I used to like playing these off against each other but now it’s just a club of incompetence and disinterest
Autoscreens came and did my cross, at the farm, it was an oem one

 

[The Panda Nut]

It's the insurance industry's version of shrinkflation.

This sort of thing is trending across the whole economy; it can be summed up as "Pay more, get less".

I sum it up more succinctly as RIP OFF. I do accept that claims are increasingly costly because of labour and other cost rises so increases are inevitable but over inflationary rises are just a RIP OFF. Not helped by Fiats parts pricing which is an even bigger RIP OFF.

I think the bottom line is we all know insurers will try everything possible to rebuff all claims so be sure NEVER to give them any ammo.

 

[jrkitching]

but over inflationary rises are just a RIP OFF

Just about everything I've bought recently seems to have gone up by way more than the rate of inflation. Service contracts which auto renew at RPI +5.9% are commonplace nowadays.

Makes me wonder just how they calculate inflation. That calculation is a rip off in its own right.

 

[porta]

Just about everything I've bought recently seems to have gone up by way more than the rate of inflation. Service contracts which auto renew at RPI +5.9% are commonplace nowadays.

Makes me wonder just how they calculate inflation. That calculation is a rip off in its own right.

It’s price gouging

 

[AAB1992]

Thought I’d just post a few pictures of what I mean. The rubber strip on the base of the screen, where the scuttle panel clips into, isn’t correct as the scuttle doesn’t clip into it far enough to sit flush no matter how much you press on it.

Moreover, I’ve just been applying some rain-x to the screen and I can feel the screen surface is not flat. It “dips” down towards the middle of the screen on both sides (manufacturing quirk!?). Yes they may all meet minimum standards but not all screens are manufactured the same high standards.

On reflection, if my insurance provider used a company that fitted an OEM screen as some have suggested theirs do on this thread, then the difference between £100 excess and “possible” increase on premiums for a couple of years would have been worthwhile vs the outright cost of supplying and fitted a genuine screen myself.

Oh well you live and learn!

 

[The Panda Nut]

Just about everything I've bought recently seems to have gone up by way more than the rate of inflation. Service contracts which auto renew at RPI +5.9% are commonplace nowadays.

Makes me wonder just how they calculate inflation. That calculation is a rip off in its own right.

I make a point of ringing and emailing the offenders and making a lot of it. SO far all have agreed to cut back to teh 10% rate. It just offends me that they all think they can carry on ripping everyone off. We are going to lose our landline if the phone company tries to raise it and do broadband via a mobile phone. Just keep an old phone permanently connected. I think it would be cheaper overall. No standing charge and disconnect if we go away and zero the cost altogether. Its just greed.

 

[daroya]

Hi all,

I had a stone chip that rapidly progressed into a massive crack before I had chance to repair it. The windscreen needs to be replaced. I'm assessing all options currently.

The car is a 2018 pop with 110k on the clock.


Option 1 - A used windscreen (approx. £90 from a 2018 model that's done 7k) and then finding someone to fit it (if anyone is willing to fit a second hand one?).

Option 2 - Via insurance (£100 excess). Then you must declare you've made a windscreen claim for 5 years. I know people seem to suggest it doesn't affect premiums but I did a test on a prospective new policy (mine has just renewed) and it did make the quote increase by an extra £35. So extrapolating that for a 5 year period it could potentially cost £275 overall in the long term.

Option 3 - Go direct to a windscreen replacement company. Does anyone know roughly how much a new screen would be? Can anyone recommend places in Yorkshire or specifically West Yorkshire?


As the car has already covered 110k and I do approximately 20k a year I don't want to be spending over the odds as I’ll be replacing the car in 18-24 months.

Let me know your thoughts on Best Car Workshop Dubai.
Adam

So I had a crack in my windscreen, not sure how I got it as I don’t recall anything hitting it! Took over a month to get the replacement. and once fitted I was advised that the car cameras and safety system needed recalibrating…. Never heard of this before but Nissan confirmed this is a requirement…. Unfortunately nearest time slot from my local dealer is over a month away(!!) so the question is, how safe is it to drive knowing the systems need recalibrating??

 

[Marcus Daly]

I assume you have a Panda with the City Brake system. If so it requires no calibration. Only newer/more sophisticated systems with cameras need this.

I queried this when I had to have my windscreen replaced and Autoglass assured me the Panda’s system only uses radar and therefore this is not an issue.