Is it not possible to just replace the center piece which is the part that is malfunctioning
It's possible; the difficulty you will have is sourcing the part. Prior to brexit/covid, these were readily available and reasonably cheap; now they're as rare as hen's teeth and usually well north of £100. Most of the parts in the UK are likely in the hands of folks offering a cluster repair service, and I doubt many of these folks would sell them separately, given the current supply chain issues.
Search the 'bay and the web and you'll find a few listings; just make 100% sure it's the right part for your car. You might need to dismantle your cluster and look for some sort of identification markings on the part itself.
Low mileage used units aren't cheap anymore; most I've seen have been listed closer to £200 than £100, often with 70k+ miles recorded. Given that this is an extremely common failure, there's no knowing how long a secondhand unit will last before that also fails in the same way. Damp is the usual reason these fail, and parts salvaged from scrap cars have often been left standing outside with broken windscreens, etc. That's not a route I'd want to take.
If you want simplicity, certainty and a warranty, a new cluster is one option. Shop4parts will do a virgin OEM cluter for 25% off, (and a further 10% if you make a
donation to this forum), but that'll still set you back somewhere around £550-£600, and will also need to be programmed using
MES. If you want to go this route, give the chaps in Bradford a call, and they'll make sure to supply the correct cluster for your car.
Sending your cluster to one of the reconditioners may be the least worst way forward. If they're able to fix it by replacing the LCD panel, it shouldn't need programming. From what I've found doing a quick search, it might not cost much more than just buying the part, and you'll have some comeback if it doesn't work.
An all-inclusive main dealer repair (new cluster + programming) will likely be £1000+ .
@typecastboy has swapped out more than a few of these; he might know a bit more about what's happening in the marketplace just now.