Technical Euro6 1.2 Throttle Response, Hill Start Issues & Watchdog report

Currently reading:
Technical Euro6 1.2 Throttle Response, Hill Start Issues & Watchdog report

Sorry but using the car or not doesn't protect your right to reject, you merely have to document the fault and show it is present. You actually have a duty to allow the seller sufficient time to repair the fault and unless they advise otherwise that it will contribute to the fault, you can continue to use the product albeit with the agreement that they are accepting that it is ongoing fault which may result in it being rejected of not fixed.

There is no evidence of acceptance while you have clearly demonstrated that you have a fault which you expect them to repair in a reasonable period of time. You are obliged to allow them reasonable time to repair the vehicle. You can't just drop a car off and reject it verbally, you have to document the reasons for rejection and that they have a final opportunity to repair the vehicle.

The only way to reject a car is if you can show there is a fault to the satisfaction of the court and that you have allowed the dealer reasonable opportunity to rectify it.

Dumping the keys and saying you are rejecting it, will not be viewed well by a court which expects you to work with the supplier to find a solution. You also need to make sure you have good documentation to show you tried to work with them, otherwise the court will simply say you need to try this first.

I have been through this process and you need to work with them.

1) I'm not sure what you quantify as 'sufficient time' given that at present, Fiat UK cannot give any timeframe on a fix coming from Italy....
2) Of course I can 'drop off a car and reject it verbally' - I have done and I'm very pleased that it's not my responsibility now. Of course I'm going to follow up my actions in writing - I've kept a very clear and detailed log of my every action since the problems came to light with the vehicle. However, I am still holding hope of hearing something from the dealership within this first week. If I haven't, however, then I will be writing to them.
3) It is not my job to show there is a fault. The dealership did their diagnostics which didn't flag anything up but the fact still remains that the car cannot cope with hill starts.
4) Dumping the keys, as you so put it, was an action taken with much courage to make a statement about how unsatisfied I am with the vehicle they have sold me. I happen to be dealing with a dealership that has shown little interest if any in assisting me with this problem and they needed to be absolutely clear in their understanding that I will NOT be satisfied until they pull their fingers out and start treating this sorry situation seriously.

And equally, they need to work with me. I have never once tried to be difficult; merely a customer who has purchased a brand new car that doesn't do what it should do. I'm sure I speak for MANY customers who feel grossly let down by their dealership who fobs you off, refers you to Fiat, and who fails to pass you any words of condolence or recognition for the disappointment that you feel. I'm gutted - and I will not be walked over.
 
Last edited:
Fair enough, it was meant to be a constructive post. Having been through this myself, I know how it works and my comments were meant to be a indication of how they will respond to it.

Couple of things, but it is vital to document to the dealer why you are rejecting the car, verbally doesn't work really as they will simply say they misunderstood or something similar. You may have done this, but you would be advised to get a dated receipt from them for the keys when you handed it back.

Unfortunately if you reject a car it is up to you to show there is a fault, it is probably the most important thing you have to do sadly. It is the entire basis for your action, hopefully Watchdog have helped with this.

As for time, you should stipulate the time you are giving them to do it, that way when they miss that date you have a reason to take the next step. Without it, there is no deadline for them to miss.

As you said the dealer/Fiat should work with you but as this is not happening, you need to be the one driving it and if it does end up in court be the one who is being the most reasonable.

Apologies if you were offended, it was not the intention. I know from my own experience it is frustrating, BUT there is a process which makes it harder to be ignored by the dealer as they know where it will ultimately lead.
 
Last edited:
All duly noted. It's an extremely frustrating situation to find myself in and one that I feel very aggrieved to have to be dealing with. It's completely tarnished the love I had for my lovely new purchase.

Given that I didn't get a receipt for the car keys last week, would it be wise for me to write to the M.D. stating that I would like them to acknowledge my actions of last Thursday, confirm that they have the keys and request that they have a further 3 weeks to identify the fault in line with that highlighted by the Watchdog report?
 
I would as you can use that date for the finance company as well when it comes to working out when you lost use of the car.

If it were me, I would list all the previous discussions/visits with the dealership in the letter (as a reminder to the garage, but also to get it in writing if required later). As a result of this you are offering them 3 weeks (or whatever you choose, 3 weeks seems more than fair) to finally deal with the fault. Send it recorded delivery as well, so you have a confirmation of receipt.

You could mention Watchdog, but if it were me, I would phrase it as "a fault which appears to be the same or similar to that highlighted in significant numbers of vehicles on the Watchdog program". That way you are not locking yourself into accepting any remedial action that Fiat identify as part of the fault in the program.

I have never done this and it could open up a can of worms, but I do wonder whether another grounds for rejection is that your insurance would be invalid if you knowingly continue to drive a defective vehicle which may impact safety.
 
I read all of your posts on the other thread. Sorry to appear rude or condescending Mick, but did it never occur to you to just ask the dealer (y)
We bought Rosa though a secondhand chappy, and we've not been near a Fiat dealer.

Rosa is just over three years old and done 14,000miles, and now out of guarantee of course.

The nearest Fiat dealer is 20miles away, but our local garage is only in the village down the road. I may pay him a visit.

Mick.
 
We bought Rosa though a secondhand chappy, and we've not been near a Fiat dealer.

Rosa is just over three years old and done 14,000miles, and now out of guarantee of course.

The nearest Fiat dealer is 20miles away, but our local garage is only in the village down the road. I may pay him a visit.

Mick.

Ok fair enough, but you could still ask a dealer over the phone ;)

My guess is they will probably want to charge c£40 to do it. They might do it for free if it's part of a service or they somehow get the impression you'd want to use them for future repairs/servicing.

Your local bloke may (should) be able to do it.

Anyhoo, we're going a bit off topic :)
 
There is a Panda thread I believe....would be good to keep this one for the 500s please!
 
I have never done this and it could open up a can of worms, but I do wonder whether another grounds for rejection is that your insurance would be invalid if you knowingly continue to drive a defective vehicle which may impact safety.

In 20+ years of car ownership, I have rejected two cars; both bizarrely within 6 months of each other. One was a Ford Ka with structural corrosion (amongst other niggles) at 3 years old which was an absolute battle with the dealer to reject as the car was drivable, if not what I considered to be "merchantable" quality.

The other was a Renault Clio which used to randomly cut out under heavy acceleration, then refuse to idle on restart so was incredibly unsafe to drive. I used the potentially invalid insurance cover argument as a successful means to reject the Clio. This was aided by, ahem, "accidentally" cutting out, abandoning the car across the dealer's car park on a busy sales day and then asking the manager to try and safely move it if he wanted his car park cleared.:D
 
As I mentioned yesterday, my dealer has said that my car is all as it should be.

However, I have now given them the code provided by Red Mitch - SN101011 and they are now "looking into it" To be fair, they seem like a decent bunch, so at this point I'm hopeful of a good outcome.

So I'm hoping this fault code has not been widely transmitted around the Fiat Dealership network (ie they are simply not aware of it yet) and that my car will be sorted as Red Mitch's seems to have been.

Fingers crossed and I'll keep you informed.
 
Just been under the bonnet checking levels etc. now the cold weathers arriving. While I was there had a quick look at the ECU.

This answers the question of how to tell a euro 6 car.

last 5 digits on the top line of the ECU label (just above the bar code) say EURO6 :D

I've taken some photo's not very good I'm afraid so you'll have to take my word for it.
 

Attachments

  • IMG-20141125-00116.jpg
    IMG-20141125-00116.jpg
    942.3 KB · Views: 99
  • IMG-20141125-00117.jpg
    IMG-20141125-00117.jpg
    132.2 KB · Views: 110
That is a great bit of work, now everybody can check and see if it only affects Euro 6 as that will either rule it out or at least point to it as a issue
 
Unable to see mine as label is stuck on lower down,will need a dentists mirror!
 
Hi guys,
Not that it applies to me or our 500TA, but where is the ECU?

I can see the battery, the air filter with the logos on and I can see lots of other things, but noting is stated as ECU.

Is there a photo of under the bonnet pointing to the bits and bobs other than the obvious?

Regards,
Mick
 
Back
Top