I don't remember an O ring there either but the old one definitely has residue similar to the water galleries on it. The one in the gasket set is a different size to the old one as well. Can't figuer out where the old one came from then again there were several botched jobs on the car when I bought it considering there were only 9500 mls on it I'm not surprised if it had spurious bits and pieces, there was PTFE tape on the sump plug!