Hi,
@Lotusanne ,
I seriously doubt that changing the antenna will solve your problem. The antenna is nothing more than a coil of wire encased in a plastic moulding. Checking for continuity with a multimeter will prove that it is intact. Having typed that I have had another thought.
As you have discovered there may be different versions of the antenna. Fiat eLearn for my x244 shows connectors at the antenna and at the code receiver, with a short connecting cable. When I was investigating my own problem, I could not find a connector at the antenna. The antenna and cable appeared to be one assembly. (I was not inclined to carry out a destructive examination,) This would make sense in reducing the number of connectors in the circuit.
If there is a connector at the antenna, this should be cleaned in a similar manner to that at the code receiver.
Part of the problem is the age of the components, as in your vehicle they will be over 20 years old, which is a good lifetime for electronic equipment. Are we trying to use 20 year old TVs, mobile phones, computers, or digital cameras? To some extent we must live in hope.
Only yesterday I looked up the electronic chip that is used in the keys, and downloaded a data sheet. One thing that stood out was the code retention, which was stated as 20 years. After that the code could presumably become corrupted.
How the system works? My knowledge is based on Fiat eLearn (electronic manual) for my x244 model which has an electronically controlled engine. I am assuming that for engines with mechanical injection will be similar, but if I get it wrong please accept my apologies.
In order to stop a diesel engine or prevent it starting, you need to cut off/prevent the supply of fuel. In your 2.8idTD engine there is an electromagnetically operated valve on the injection pump (fuel cut off valve), For the engine to run,his valve must have a 12V supply from the ignition switch.
The key code system interupts this supply, inside the secure cover on the pump.
The chip in the key is a micro computer with no external wires. It works in a similar manner, to contactless credit/debit cards.
When ignition is switched on, the code receiver, which is also a transmitter, and the unit on the pump receive power.
The code receiver transmits a small amount of power via the antenna to the key chip., and reads the code stored in the key chip., which is transmitted back to the code receiver, which has valid codes stored in memory. Normally the key is accepted, and the code light is turned off. (This last part could be more complicated.)
At the same time in human perception, the pump unit asks the code receiver for a stored
unlock code. This code is only sent to the pump if the code reseiver has recognised the key code as one stored in its own memory. Provided that the pump electronics receive the correct code from the code receiver, then it should connect the 12V from the ignition switch to tp fuel cut off solenoid. Engine should then start when cranked.
Any queries?
If anyone can improve on this basic explanation, please edit and repost.
Possible causes of failure.
My own theory is that the signals to and from the antenna are of low voltage, and are unable to overcome oxide films om connector contacts. I had two failures in five attempts last March. Connector contacts cleaned and no failures since.
@Anthony489 has suggested that radio components (key chip & code receiver) may go off tune.
Failure of components with age, and repeated heating and cooling. I suspect that
@ThorRoger 's pump unit has a micro crack in an electronic component. He cannot start a warm engine, unless he pours water on the pump shield to cool it.
As vehicles get older, then possibly all of the above could apply.