In other words;
threads like "Oh.. X is broken, where can I get one?" ... "you can get it at such and such a place" is ok...
whereas..
"I have many parts for sale at my Fiat Uno shop, just visit this website or PM to buy something" would not be ok.
I think...
Yes, that's right.
Please see rules at https://www.fiatforum.com/rules.html
Any advertisment not specifically directed to anyone will just get deleted straight away. Especially when the poster has a low post count and is clearly not a 'true' forum member (in which case, they will most likely get 'banned' while I am at it).
The only slight problem is that the rules don't define what 'advertising' is.
If you or I suggest where to buy something in the middle of a genuinely-intended-to-be-helpful post, then I believe that's not advertising. It's a recommendation. I realise the system might be open to abuse, but (as with many things in life) I think we need to allow this discretion.
So - in summary...
1. If your post is directed to one particular person (such as a reply on a thread), then it's OK to advise of something for sale or something wanted. As in, "I have one of those, PM me." Then wait for their message. Send a private message ONLY if that person could reasonably expect to receive a message from you.
2. If your post is of general interest and not directed to one particular person, and is either advertising something for sale or requesting an item, it needs to be placed as a classified ad.
3. There is a whole 'Auction Watch' section intended for a third category of 'advertisement' - where you just want to share something you've found on eBay.
4. I intend to apply that discretion I mentioned a moment ago to any general-audience post, from an actual forum member, that does not fit any of the three categories above.
A hypothetical example: suppose Chas starts a new thread to report a mint-condition Uno for sale on the side of the road in Watford. Clearly, this is not 1) because it is not a reply to a thread and not directed to any one person, it is not 2) because it's not Chas that's selling the Uno (you cannot place a classified ad on behalf), and it is not 3) because the Uno for sale isn't on eBay. I feel we need to allow such posts, because they are interesting and potentially very helpful.
I think I should make this a sticky soon. All comments appreciated.
-Alex