Yes they are the same just the plastic carrier differs a bit on L and r side. New panda, also doblo from 2005 on and possibly AR 156 Restyling ( from 2003) all fit. Ebay is a good place to sometimes snag a bargain, also DEPO Taiwan makes cheap substitute parts. It's not the hardest job but it is a bit tricky, best done with a car raised on a lift, there is an access flap on the bottom of the bumper cover but it is still a tight fit especially for the last of the three screws holding the fog light.