It is natural that over time a screw will seize or break when loosened. In any case, it must be replaced with a specified tensile strength. And tightened with the specified torque. I would never replace a screw of a supposed quality, say 8.8! There is a quality mark on the screws, and you can buy a new one based on this. The 8.8 quality is mostly for structural steel connections. I always buy the screws that need replacement based on the parts catalog of the given car. It is common for cars to use screws with high tensile strength, possibly with low thread pitch (fine thread). In summary, the wear of the screw is natural. But it is not appropriate to put it back if it is broken. It must be replaced in any case.