The turbo on your car is a different T15, the one you have is off a early Golf TDi, they are not interchangeable. The reason is down to orientation, as the turbo is held on by 3 studs, yours is in effect 120degress different to the Astra turbo.
I did see a manifold that had been modified to accept a T2 turbo from Italy, standard turbo modified in much the same way as the VAD ones are, only differance being the mount was much nicer as the T2 flange is a large rectangle its an almost perfect fit to the manifold that once cut at correct place is also a rectangle. Whereas the T15 has a small round opening that is offset causing poor gas flow and an area that gets very hot, the internal baffle inside the manifold that separates the ports into two i.e 1&2 3&4 eventually just breaks up due to the heat so its good to remove that. I know someone who had the misfortune off breaking a turbo because a piece of this fell into the turbo and damage the blades. So T2 better gas flow, no hot spots, probably spool up as quickly due to that.
Another benefit is that you can bolt up the turbo correctly, on the T15's unless the turbo is modified the studs eventually bend causing a leak between manifold and turbo, doesn't matter how well the car is looked after, the heat wand weight will get there in the end, so the back of turbo has to be modified flat to ensure that when its bolted up the studs remain straight, this should prolong any leaks from forming. This is because normally the turbo has the studs and its the manifold that bolted to the turbo on the factory fitted cars. The T2 by virtue of its design is meant to be bolted to a manifold so modification is needed.
T2's off R5GTT's are except from very early models, water cooled, so if fitting one you would need to look at modifying your coolant system. The good thing about T2's is they are popular and easy to get hold off as used in many many variants.
I think a T2 on a 1242 install would be fine, the R5GTT is 1397cc, so not that much bigger, and the MG Metro Turbo was a 1275cc running a much bigger T3 with only 0.5bar of boost, so it can be done.
Another thing is this, a bigger turbo flowing the same amount of boost is working less hard, so the air is not as hot meaning you make more power.