SteveNZ said:
This is a common mistake. The handbrake does not actually need to be balanced, only the service brake needs to be balanced. The handbrake
only needs to pass the performance test. Stop in 18m at 30km/hr or one of the equilivent tests. 1/5 test, stall test.
Please see
http://www.landtransport.govt.nz/publications/vir-manual/general-vehicles/8-brakes-v2-3.pdf
I think we're both right on this one. Paragraph 34 states (as a reason for failure
34. When the parking brake is applied:
...
c) it does not hold all the wheels on a common axle stationary against attempts to drive the vehicle away.
Other two requirements were exactly as you stated (and I think c) is what you mean by the stall test). Obviously though, if one side was not as strong as the other side, the wheel would turn - and that would be a fail under c).
Come to that, have you ever failed to drive away in a car with the handbrake on? So I suppose that means most cars would fail c).
My local WOF station (not VTNZ) just tests the handbrake on the rollers and if imbalanced, it's a fail. I think they quoted 50% as the maximum imbalance they allow. So if I want a WOF, my handbrake needs to work evenly - or I could perhaps find somewhere else for a WOF...
There's probably also a rule somewhere that allows testing stations to be more stringent than necessary!
uno170bhp - I think you should only replace the caliper once you've cleaned/lubricated the cables (a more likely cause) and also ask to see the result of the service brake (footbrake) test. If that was balanced OK, then that rules out discs/pads or the caliper sliding pins.
-Alex