Thanks for all the help guys, appreciated
Is it really necessary to be changing the brake fluid every two years as part of the service though as according to fiat service schedule? I understand what you guys have said about moisture getting in over time and affecting the operation but the fiat service schedule is based on doing 8/9k miles a year which our 500 doesn’t do at all. My other cars (german) don’t have to have the brake fluid changed in the same time schedule as the Fiat according to their manufacturer schedules, which is why I find it a bit excessive. So should I still be doing it every 2 years we’ve though the mileage isn’t done?
Thanks
I have a SEAT Ibiza and have owned a number of VAG products over the years. My belief is that they (VAG) recommend the first brake fluid change is done at year 3 and then every 2 years thereafter? Certainly that seems to be the recommendation up here. In my opinion age is the biggest factor here, not mileage?
The trouble is there's a lot of variables involved in trying to predict when the fluid may have absorbed enough moisture for it to have a significant effect. For instance - How often is the reservoir cap removed? Was it removed on a damp rainy day or a very dry sunny summer's day? If it's been topped up was it topped up from a brand new sealed container or a previously opened, part used, one? - You get the idea?
Whether you ever experience a driving problem due to this also part of the problem. Having worked in and around the motor trade for much of my life, I can tell you that I've seen many cars with pretty dodgy looking, very dark coloured, brake fluid in their reservoirs but most are driving around the town without crashing because their brake calipers do not get hot enough to boil the water content. Then, maybe, off they go on holiday and perhaps, on a sweltering hot day, have to do an emergency stop from high speed on the motorway or perhaps descend a very steep long hill (I remember my old Ford Anglia with it's drum brakes, on holiday, fully laden with self, wife, kids, and other holiday gear really struggling with brake fade going down the hill into Lynmouth North Devon. Brake fade, of course, is a quite different problem to having water in the fluid, but having very little braking available with a steep hill in front is terrifying. Luckily we were early on that day and traffic was not heavy so I got away with it) Our workshop would always recommend that "dirty looking" fluid be flushed and renewed but then another problem raises it's head which is that many vehicles with contaminated fluid will be older so there's always a risk the bleed nipples will shear due to being seized in their threads. If you mention this to the customer and warn them of the cost implication many will choose not to do it. In my opinion there are a lot of older "time bombs" running around out there and although the majority are never going to have an "incident" it might just be you who gets "unlucky".
From the mechanic's point of view I would want to change it anyway because of it's potential to cause corrosion of cylinder/caliper pistons and other components in the braking system - ABS unit's ain't cheap!
I have to plead guilt to having been just a little less than "holy" in my own approach to this in the past, especially when a nipple has broken off but not started leaking - which is often what happens when a nipple snaps off - and, due to lack of money, I've not replaced the caliper/cylinder and run on with the old fluid in the system until I've either found a good used caliper or saved enough for a new one.
Today though folks, Hallelujah salvation is to hand! because you can buy a brake fluid tester which tests the fluid itself for water content! There are two types. The cheaper ones pass a current between two electrodes immersed in the fluid and measure the electrical resistance. They have been criticized because not all fluids have the same resistance when new but I believe the better tools allow a calibration to be made in new fluid before you use it to check the used fluid. Trouble is you probably won't know what brand of fluid is in your reservoir so how do you know you're calibration in that bottle of new fluid you've bought is going to be valid for the fluid in your reservoir? However I doubt if the difference between brands is going to be a large one? So I still think they are a good idea - but buy a "known" branded tool.
The better option - in my opinion - are the tools which heat the brake fluid to the point at which it boils. This will vary depending on the moisture content. I believe this type of tool is considerably more accurate and is not dependent on the resistance of the fluid because it directly checks the boiling point rather than trying to "guess" what the boiling point may be due to the electrical resistance of the fluid. This is the one I bought and I have to say it seems to be working very well:
You simply connect those "frighteningly" thick leads to the car's battery, dunk the probe in and out of the fluid a few times to stabilize the probe temperature, and then keep it there while you press the big red button. When it's happy, it gives a readout of actual boiling point of the fluid which you compare to the chart in the second picture. (The written instructions give much more detail) It's also suggested that if there's any doubt that fresh fluid may have been recently added to the reservoir that fluid is taken from the N/S front wheel, using the syringe and decanted to the wee cup where the tester is used in the same way to obtain a boiling point figure.
Of course you need to be aware that the fluid in the reservoir may very well have been topped up at some time so if you use any type of tester in the reservoir the reading obtained may not be reflecting what's in the components at the "business" end of the system! One of the big advantages of doing your own service and repair work is, of course, that you will know though!
So, if you don't have some way of ascertaining the degree of degradation of the fluid the best you can do is guess how long the average vehicle takes to end up with significant amounts of moisture in the fluid and the manufacturer's seem to be mostly of the opinion that two to three years is what they're prepared to risk recommending. Thus the widely adopted recommendation to completely renew fluid at this sort of interval.