what do you think of the seat ibiza???

ok as you know and may be siuck of this, but my car short list has come to theses 2 cars

1) seat ibiza

2) fiat punto

but i am getting very tempted to go for the ibiza or the puto so i am keeping my options open

thanks

rich

Punto is Italian, Ibiza is made from old Voltswagen parts, need i say more!

Go Italian, great engines although Voltwagen do make some as well

punto of course :bang:

The Ibiza has less leg room in the back than my cinq does! New shape one that is...


They have great engines in them now and the TDi's Fly for a diesel...

Punto!! Italian Style!!! Need I say more!!

I live in Barcelona, Spain, and here, most people buy the inpersonal VAG Ibiza, I prefer Punto mk2, or mk2b Sporting instead of Ibiza.

Punto is a better car, in my opinion

Hang on, just having a look...

yep, it says:



what do you think we're going to say

I bucked the trend this time....

So out of a choice of punto HGT or Ibiza FR which one hey guys (and girls)

Ibiza FR it's not comparable with HGT.....

HGT its similar to 206 gti's.... the FR goes near the 180hp!!!!!

The only Ibiza I like are the FR and Cupra versions, the standard Ibiza sucks.... I don't like it

speed said:

Ibiza FR it's not comparable with HGT.....

HGT its similar to 206 gti's.... the FR goes near the 180hp!!!!!

The only Ibiza I like are the FR and Cupra versions, the standard Ibiza sucks.... I don't like it

Click to expand...

Why not compareable?

Is the HGT not the top of the range punto?

Is the FR not the top of the range ibiza?

Both designed with the same people in mind so I would say they are!

What are the prices new? I have no idea?!

SEAT Ibiza
1.8 20V T FR 3d 2004/54
Insurance Group 13
Average mileage: 10,000 miles
Cost New ('04) £ 12932
Franchised Dealer £ 9660I
ndependent Dealer £ 9175
Private Good £ 8615
Private Poor £ 7005
Part Exchange £ 7890



Fiat Punto Hatchback
1.8 HGT 3d 2004/54
Insurance Group 14
Average mileage: 10,000 miles
Cost New ('04) £ 12177
Franchised Dealer £ 8370
Independent Dealer £ 7695
Private Good £ 7220
Private Poor £ 5870
Part Exchange £ 6615

ok i get your point, just thinking about it at the moment

thanks

rich

THought you picked the clio?

THe cupra is well above the HGT but the FR appears to not be far off....though I assume it can be tuned much higher having a turbo.

The Negotiator said:

THought you picked the clio?

THe cupra is well above the HGT but the FR appears to not be far off....though I assume it can be tuned much higher having a turbo.

Click to expand...

no changed my mind about that one

Your regret it if you buy the Seat

When ever your on the M1 and a punto flies buy, your kick yourself.

A Seat has no get up and go, unlike the sprit de Punto (had to say it)

fiatpuntosx said:

Your regret it if you buy the Seat

When ever your on the M1 and a punto flies buy, your kick yourself.

A Seat has no get up and go, unlike the sprit de Punto (had to say it)

Click to expand...

Right some fiats are quick but..... check out the figures and how fast the cars are

Exactly....

The Negotiator said:

Exactly....

Click to expand...

Ok i exagerated abit

The Negotiator said:

Exactly....

Click to expand...

Oh no he agrees!!!

Monumental occasion!

Really should put my pro FIAT head back on...

Ok the Punto looks 10x Better!