Would you hit a woman? Men only please.

Currently reading:
Would you hit a woman? Men only please.

Would you hit a Woman? Question is for Men only please.

  • Yes

    Votes: 14 32.6%
  • No

    Votes: 29 67.4%

  • Total voters
    43
  • Poll closed .
Joined
Sep 29, 2008
Messages
6,174
Points
1,379
Location
Wolverhampton
I'm a little surprised by the amount of male members that would hit a woman.

I know there are extreme circumstances we can all think up to justify giving her one on the chin but this question doesn't include the James Bond type scenario's where you had to kill her or the world would end.

I'm talking stuff like:

A girl in a night club has a go at you, false nails and hair extensions flying all over the place.

The missus comes home drunk and starts arguing and throwing punches at you.

Your sister(now an adult) picks a fight with you.

Get the idea?

Be truthful, the pole is anonymous.
 
Only if provoked, for example burning my tea, not doing as she's told etc.

Seriously though, it's a tricky one, if somebody attacks you then you can morally & legally use force to defend yourself however you may be able to do so without actually hitting them.

For example if you're a 6'4" 18 stone bloke you shouldn't need to punch a 7 stone woman to defend yourself.

The other issue to consider is that if you do thump a woman in self defence & somebody sees you do it you stand a good chance of getting a good kicking for your trouble
 
I can't believe you actually made this a poll shadey!!

It's not as clear cut as would or wouldn't you hit a woman. I've been reading the thread that this started from and I agree with Maxi.

It's all about the circumstances. If I was hysterical and need a good slap to calm me down I would expect the nearest man to do as much as a woman. If I was being violent towards a man I would expect him to fight back, if I didn't want him to fight back I wouldn't pick a fight!

If I just made my OH's dinner and it wasn't up to scratch and got a slap for it that's a no no that domestic abuse. Even the other way there are men out there getting abused by there wives/partner.

I'm sorry but for the first time very I'm seriously offend by a thread on this forum. Now when I joined this forum I was well aware that it was a male dominated forum and that there would be a fair amount of ***** measuring but it's getting out of hand. Between this, the thread this started in and the how does this work thread it's getting beyond a joke.

Can't all you boys just agree to disagree, everyone has a different opinions about things that's life that's what makes the world so interesting.

End rant/
 
I can't believe you actually made this a poll shadey!!

It's not as clear cut as would or wouldn't you hit a woman. I've been reading the thread that this started from and I agree with Maxi.

It's all about the circumstances. If I was hysterical and need a good slap to calm me down I would expect the nearest man to do as much as a woman. If I was being violent towards a man I would expect him to fight back, if I didn't want him to fight back I wouldn't pick a fight!

If I just made my OH's dinner and it wasn't up to scratch and got a slap for it that's a no no that domestic abuse. Even the other way there are men out there getting abused by there wives/partner.

I'm sorry but for the first time very I'm seriously offend by a thread on this forum. Now when I joined this forum I was well aware that it was a male dominated forum and that there would be a fair amount of ***** measuring but it's getting out of hand. Between this, the thread this started in and the how does this work thread it's getting beyond a joke.

Can't all you boys just agree to disagree, everyone has a different opinions about things that's life that's what makes the world so interesting.

End rant/

Not wanting to upset you in anyway but did you read the title of this thread?
 
Last edited:
it's a public forum anyone can read your poll and i didn't vote i just commented on the poll

I've seen what happens when a woman stands in front of a man poking him and hiting him telling him and everyone else its ok for him to hit her.

He eventually did, she woke up 9 hours later with a punctured eyeball(caused by his ring) a fractured eye socket, 4 missing teeth, a broken jaw and a 2 inch cut on the back of her head where she hit the floor.

This was from one punch. I had to give evidence on his behalf(self deffence-one punch), he was provoked, his face was a wash with bruises and scratches from the woman. He was sentenced to 2 years for GBH.

May I suggest you not allow a male to slap, punch you or anything else under any circumstances, for his sake if not your own.

As you chose to ignore my request for men only I choose to ignore any further posts by yourself in this thread.
 
Lol ofcourse it was gbh. There is such a thing as reasonable force. Your mate sounds like nothing more than a thug.

Firstly he wasn't my mate.

Secondly 2 years for GBH was far too serious a sentence IMO.

He was an indian fella called Pomy(nik name), he used a club in Birmingham and I was a bouncer there. He had broken up with his girlfriend accross the road from the club. Myself and another bouncer saw and heard everything, he hit her once and didn't move one inch untill the old bill arrested him. We gave statements to the old bill and were later asked to give evidence on his behalf.
 
No 2 years is right for knocking someone out with such force you break all the bones in tje side of their head.
I am not surprised you think you mate was treated harshly you do give tue impression of someone who thinks violence is fine when you see fit.
 
Are you saying using reasonable force is the same as punching a woman unconscieus and disfiguring her?

ive seen cases where a man has punched a man with 1 punch doing same kind of damage and getting off when witnesses have said the other bloke started the fight, so to be equal rights..........


unless you go around punching people all the time how do you know what your punch can do to some one else?
 
Last edited:
Back
Top