This thread is STILL going
My driving instructor's car was a 1994 Toyota Corona (Carina in the UK) which was three years old at the time, and while it may have had a hard life, it was unforgettable how:
- it failed to start (flooded itself)
- it overheated (fan didn't work)
- it overheated again (thermostat/water pump/who knows)
- the speedometer stopped working
- a gearchange cable fell off
- the brakes slowly locked themselves on - very embarrassing, but very funny when the instructor couldn't move it either
...the fifth week, we took my 1974 FIAT 128 Coupe instead and it performed flawlessly.
I think the real test of reliability is whether you actually get from A to B. Any other faults are just incidental and have to be allowed-for when you consider the age/price of the vehicle. This doesn't excuse the faults experienced by Grande Punto or Stilo owners, but in my mind it makes Toyota totally unacceptable, since it failed the A-to-B criteria four times!
I have owned one Japanese car (15 Italian cars), and it was a Toyota - silly me - a 1990 Celica - which broke a driveshaft. The ABS stopped working and the engine suddenly leaked out most of its oil through a blown main seal (but those didn't stop me getting from A to B: the driveshaft did). I didn't own the Celica for very long (a couple of months), but also had to replace an electric window and an electric mirror. Who says Italian electrics are bad...
I may be the only person in the world to have been let down in so many ways by Japanese cars, while clocking up thousands of trouble-free kilometres in Alfa Romeo 164s. I just don't touch Japanese cars any more.
-Alex