Here's most of my experience of a 4x4 TA '63 plate.
I purchased the car with 45k miles on the clock from the original supplying Main Dealer. It had limited service history (read on) and so I negotiated the (already reasonably low) price lower.
"Ticka-ticka-ticka" sounds normal to me...
First up they had done the usual dealer trick of "stealing" parts off the car to fit to others on the forecourt, this one was missing rear headrests, rear parcel shelf and inflation kit (no spare as standard). All of these were replaced without much fuss but I'm not sure that any would have been if I hadn't noticed. The point being know what to expect as "standard equipment" and insist it's there!
At 50k miles the engine lost (a lot of) power and was effectively running on one cylinder, long story short, the eventual diagnosis was the Uniair module which essentially provides the variable valve timing. There's quite a lot written about this on this site and a really good technical bulletin on the INA site (Schaeffler Technologies). Key to its longevity appears to be regular oil changes
with the right grade did I say check the service history? Also, if possible, check the right grade used in the service history, I'd definitely advocate using the recommended brand too.
Around this time the clutch failed, I think this was probably exacerbated by the loss of power (above) and the required much slipping of the clutch to get the car to move. Anyway... the TA has a dual mass flywheel (DMF) which was reported as failed too. This explained the horrible rattle/vibration through the gearstick, especially through 2nd and 3rd gears.
Still with me? Since then I've replaced a ball joint on the front suspension (along with the attached wishbone(!)) This I did myself and while it requires some patience it isn't too tricky (lots of YouTube stuff for the 500 is relevant) this has been the only MOT fail in 4 years.
I've replaced front and rear discs, more because I'm a fussy engineer, but the rears were getting a bit flaky (corroded) probably because they don't do much. The rear discs are designed to be replaced(!) contrary to some urban myths (perpetuated by some threads on here too) you don't have to pull bearings or remove hubs etc. There's just a sequence to follow and a couple of us have detailed that on here (was it
yellowtaxi ?) I don't recall. There's a YouTube for 500 Arbath rear discs which is close but not quite the same as the 4x4.
More recently the intelligent battery sensor (IBS...) has been swapped and the Stop Start became available for a while!
There were a spate of warning light issues all related (if distant cousins) to the ABS system, these included hill-holder unavailable, ESC, ABS and 4WD warning lights (the message seems to be Don't Panic) all of this nonsense was sorted by replacing the brake light switch... By the way the brake lights did still work :bang: It seems this switch has a normally open AND normally closed function which feeds messages to the control software. I still haven't heard a really plausible explanation.
Finally, mine has a flashing odometer. This is symptomatic of the Blue & Me unit failing, the engine management system can't identify the module (its a CanBUS thing). Choices here are to replace the Blue & Me unit at £450 from FIAT, get a secondhand one or go for a third party solution (i believe this will use the steering wheel controls). Any of these require the system being reset to recognize the change, or removal of the unit. The point here is check that Blue & Me works if you have the USB and Aux sockets (down by the cup holder in the central console).
So, if you are still reading, I really enjoy driving the car and don't find the 4x4 "clunky" at all in its operation, it makes the car very reassured on dry or wet conditions. The low first gear? Well you want it to be drivable off road...
Oh, one other point, I found it relatively cheap to insure for my (student) son and daughter to be learner drivers in and to drive subsequently.
Oh, and it's now done 75k miles and definitely responds to "super" grade unleaded which adds even more pep and improves fuel consumption. And a word on fuel consumption figures. I can with care (while still enjoying) get low 40s mpg and have never got near the official figures but then I don't use the ECO button either.
I hope this helps? No recommendations just experiences. The driver's seat bolster has cracked up on mine too.