How was your buying..and first user.. experience Jock?
Charlie
Hi Charlie.
I'd come across mentions of
Multiecuscan (think I saw mention of it being called Fiatecuscan?) before when looking for info on our old Felicity - 1992 Panda) and read with great interest about people on the forum using it in the days before I registered on the forum. So when we replaced Felicity with Becky and my boy bought his Punto, and I discovered I couldn't reset the service reminders without a scanner, and then that Becky and the Punto have so much more electronic "stuff" than dear old Felicity, it really was not difficult to decide to buy
MES.
Obtaining the software of course is the easy bit, anyone can download from the
MES site. So, as recommended by forum members, I downloaded it and had a play with the simulations. There's a lot that's different to VCDS but the program is actually quite a lot more user friendly. Just takes a while to get the head round it. It is a less powerful program than VCDS but I have found that I don't do the more complicated, and risky, procedures that the VCDS program allows because I don't want to risk my ignorance to allow me to damage stuff (for instance long coding?). So actually the simpler nature of
MES was an attraction.
Ok, so I'd decided to buy. Having owned VAG-COM (now called VCDS) for a number of years I had become used to just plugging the one interface in and having access to all of the computer modules on my VAG vehicles in one go. One of the ways in which I use it is to do a whole vehicle scan for stored codes before starting almost any work on the vehicle, that way I know if something flags up subsequently it's almost certainly been caused by something "stupid" I've done whilst working on it, but also I then know if something, perhaps not covered in the service procedure, is requiring to be looked at. So I didn't like the way that
MES has different interfaces for the different ECUs. Then I spotted the Multplexed interface which is pretty much exactly what the VCDS one is. It was pretty much no contest then as regards which interface to buy but it did take a wee while to justify to myself spending the money it costs.
It was around this time that I first made contact with Gendan and it was Grant who picked up the 'phone. I must have rung him at least a half dozen times with "silly" questions trying to make up my mind to buy and he even answered a couple about my VCDS - which I didn't buy from them - He was always very patient and incredibly helpful. We now quite regularly exchange emails and I can't speak highly enough about him. Just of late I've been trying to read fuel trims on the Panda and Punto and he's been very helpful. The Magneti Marrelli control units don't display fuel trims in the way the Bosch ones (in the VAG stuff) do. If you are unsure about anything do give them a ring.
Fortunately another part of my hobby activities is renovating vintage horticultural machinery. Which I then keep and use. Local people are aware of this so, occasionally, someone will gift me an old strimmer or other machine which they've broken and replaced with a new one. I keep them for spares, however often they are repairable but, being newer models, are not of special interest to me. I decided to Gumtree a couple of my less "precious" possessions and managed to, nearly, raise enough funds! I ordered the Multiplex version from Gendan and it arrived very quickly indeed. By the way, if you are going to buy the multiple lead version - which is much more economical to buy and most people seem, unsurprisingly, to go for this option - I've come across many posts, and other stuff on the wider internet, describing the problems people have had with "cheapoe" interfaces bought on line. Has to be said though that some seem to work just fine. My Electronic skills do not extend to component level so I can't start "fiddling" about with, for instance, removing resistors etc. I would strongly recommend buying from a trusted source. (for me that means Gendan. By the way, I have no vested interest in Gendan other than hoping they continue to give me the valued support they give to me right now)
With the Multiplexed version the drivers etc are all installed on the interface itself so you can download the version of the software you have paid for onto as many computers as you like and switch the interface between them. The multi lead versions only work on the one machine. Getting the interface to work was the only bit I had a little difficulty with. It didn't like the COM port my laptop wanted it to work with so I had to learn how to change the assigned COM port and then it didn't want to work with the assigned speed rate (forget what it's called). The drop down menu gives optional speeds so I just started switching between them until I found one that worked (which turned out to be 115200 - if that helps anyone) I got a lot of help from both Grant and forum members with this - I think you were one and so was PB if I remember. Also has to be said that I created problems for myself by not, very carefully, reading the installation instructions that came with the interface?
So then I had it all up and running, plugged it into the cars and a clicked "Scan DTC". Yikes, both cars showing DTCs! including ABS, body control module, etc, etc. I'm not too bad with engine stuff but not so good with others so this frightened me. I wrote it all down on a piece of paper and cleared all the stored faults. None came back immediately (ie when the car was driven round the block) so I then rechecked the Panda after a couple of days and it was still all clear. Checked the Punto after about a month (it lives at my boy's house) and it had stayed clear too. I've since discovered that, occasionally, random codes will be thrown which seem to have no good explanation for why they've appeared. Of course you should consider the implications of the code but often if you just clear them they will not return. If it comes back quite quickly then you know you've definitely got a problem though - I always take a note of the code before clearing.
So, now a couple of years down the line with
MES what do I think of it? I absolutely wouldn't be without it! You can run real time outputs etc under "Parameters" and graph their outputs (I find graphing especially useful. for instance Oxygen sensors, comparing pre and post cat outputs can help quickly and reliably diagnose cat problems. or you might want to look at alternator output to check a diode problem, and so on and so on. Just check the box against what you want to graph whilst in "Parameters" and then click on "Graph"). Of course you can check for stored trouble codes (DTCs - Diagnostic Trouble Codes) and if it finds one it very helpfully suggests likely reasons - you still need to think it through though. For instance if it says a sensor is at fault it could be a connector or lead problem - all the ECU knows is that it's not getting the response from the sensor it expects. I love being able to "drive" components. The software prompts you with what to expect when you activate a component which is very helpful when you first start. For instance the slow speed on the radiator fan in my boy's Punto didn't seem to be working so I could drive slow speed and them high speed which allowed me to find that the resistor (on the radiator surround) is open circuit due to corrosion - needs a new one. His air con hasn't worked for some time so I was also able to drive the compressor clutch and found it to be working but I've subsequently found that the slow speed rad fan needs to be functional before the aircon will run. I've got a new resistor pack sitting waiting to be fitted when I'm allowed so It'll be interesting to see if the aircon "wakes up". Then there's "Adjustments" which varies from vehicle to vehicle, but for instance allows the "Phonic wheel relearn" if you get problems with the check engine light illuminating after doing a timing belt on the 8 valve FIRE engines. The only thing which really frightens me is a "Proxy Alignment" as it seems you can do a lot of damage if you don't get it right. Haven't needed to do one so far though!
I could go on with this for ages. So I think it best to say that if, like me, you do most of your own repair and maintenance work on your Fiat/Alfa/Suzuki SX4 then you really can't do without it. It helps if you have some diagnostic knowledge before you start but the program is so user friendly that it really does lead you by the nose and if you find yourself really up a blind ally some time you can get on here and plumb the membership for advice (and there are a lot of people on here who use
MES often) or you can ring up Gendan (especially if you buy from them) Grant was very helpful when I had trouble getting my windows 10 laptop to speak to the interface. By the way, I'm a strong believer in connecting with a wired connection. When you start getting into things a bit more deeply if you are connected on bluetooth (for instance) and you were to loose the connection in the middle of doing something critical it could all end in tears. So it's wired for me.
If you are, like me, besotted with motor vehicles, you'll find you learn something new nearly every time you connect up. Then when you begin to understand more about it all there is a plethora of tutorials on you tube which will keep you occupied for hours. Although you are learning on a Fiat, a lot of this stuff - but be careful because not all - is generically applicable to most other vehicles. Beware though because you'll then find you want to buy a more generic scanner and a good one of them ain't cheap! Have a look at the Foxwell stuff, I don't think they charge for software updates? which is a major consideration over the years. By the way, because it's simple (relatively) to use and understand compared to VCDS, I've learned and understood things about how components etc work through using
MES which I've then subsequently been able to benefit from when on my VCDS.
So, Go on, buy one. You know you want to! It's a lot more fun sitting in the car on a nice warm summer evening "playing" with your
MES than sitting in the living room whilst your Mrs watches Eastenders or endless repeats of people being shown houses they are not going to buy by presenters who laugh far to much at inappropriate moments.
Stay safe everyone
Jock