My local fiat dealer is run by morons.

Currently reading:
My local fiat dealer is run by morons.

jug said:
ok calm down. is there really any need to get so wound up? :rolleyes:

i'm not seriously suggesting all dealers are run by morons, or that the staff are any worse qualified or less capable than the staff at independants. i know many people who work at dealerships and they're a valuable source of information. over the years i've saved many hours and £££'s thanks to their advice. no one knows more about a certain manufacturer's models than the techs at its dealers.

i have actually heard the saying "if it all goes wrong just join a dealership" at more than one independant over the years. people say that at independants because they dont like dealerships. i'm sure the feeling is mutual in many cases. i dont really know why that is, i just picked it up while i was doing a bit of fiddle work at a few independants. its a common thing to say to a lazy new starter (e.g. me!), phrases such as "get your socks pulled up or you'll end up a dealership" aren't uncommon. another example is "you're so slow only a dealer could afford you". if you worked on the floor at a few independants you would no doubt hear similar things. i expect the same happens at dealerships, only the insult is in reference to an independant rather than a dealership.

you said "I've seen time and time again completely useless and unthought out posts from you which constantly offend ordinary working people! (pointed out time and time again by many FF members...) "
i dont think you'll find many posts that have caused a negative reaction. i also believe you'll have a hard time finding more than 3 people who I've offended, including yourself. on the whole i try to offer technical advice to forum members based on my own experience in the industry. i can honestly say 90% of my posts have no personal opinion at all and are simply advice designed to help people with faults on their cars. if you check my previous posts you will find this is true. i admit that i do occasionally post topics which are designed to get a reaction. it does not mean i actually believe or agree with the sentiments of my post. they are certainly not "unthought out" as you say. it is more often the case that the content of the post has indeed been thought out and posted purely with the aim of getting a reaction, such as the reaction you have had. i enjoy winding people up, and when you make it so easy can you really blame me. if you learn to let it go over your head i wont be able to get you in future and you'll win. if you bite i've won.

You just come across as very stupid opinionated and insulting.
 
Two dealers near me are terrible but I have found one now which is good and know what a hgt is! Bit of a drive but they've helped me out a few times.
 
Oh I never noticed this post! so no doubt you know i'm gonna chip in with another long boring post......so grap a cuppa & biscuits,get comftable & I will begin................

In reference to alot of the question raised throught this thread...

Profit on new Fiat cars is very small(parts aint much better especially if 'rush' ordered),Fiat pay dealer no diagnostic time on warranty jobs,people with older Fiats are reluctant to take cars to dealer because of high labour rates(which is infact wrong as most dealer rates are cheaper than other makes,obviously there is variation to different parts of the country,however most dealers do cheaper labour rates for older Fiats......still want to run a Fiat dealership? certain your going to make a healthy profit now? alot of dealers are dumping Fiat for more profitable makes so the only other solution is to 'double'(or triple)up & be a dealer for another make at the same time.
There is little money in warranty work...the money is in retail work...take the stilo spring recall along with grande punto 'plate' recall,how many 'productive' hours of a techs time will this take up per week? One hell of a f*cking lot & this means there is less time for retail/sales work end result is monthly figures are low....still want to run a Fiat dealership now?

Another way of generating income is for dealers to sell other makes secondhand...a good salesman can 'sway' a potential customer away from that secondhand corsa in the sales lot to a punto;) If not well a sell is better than none at all.

Dealerships are a business not a charity...they are there(like all business)to make a profit.Large dealerships (pendragon,arnold clark,vardy's etc) exist because they have the buying power in cars & parts,they also have the financial might for technician training(especially arnold clark who invest millions in training which is why alot oftechnicians with ambition go there from other dealerships)which costs around £3-400 per day plus lost labour hours for the duration of course plus still paying technicians wages...they also have to cover costs of all tooling,diagnostic equipment,refuse collection(including fluids).subscriptions to diagnostic software and the usual rates/electric,insurance,heating etc.

'faster-tec' mentioned base models for many reasons another reason is mobility cars which is big money to any dealership...because mobility only pays a set amount base models are popular.

I disagree with Jug on monkeys joining dealerships...all I see around(and hear)me is people getting the boot because they dont come up to scratch.Every technician is monitored & if a tech does not 'pull hes weight' it is noticed as every job is recorded with a 'efficency' ratio...if its low your out! There is also no 'lazy time' every technician has to account for every minute of the day! A dealership will not waste money training etc on a poor technician.I would say alot of technicians come from independants to large dealerships for job security.My 'coffee break' consists of a 15min break in morning & 30mins for dinner...thats of course assuming I get them & without interuption...I start at 8am and lucky to finish at 6pm,I no longer have dinner with my family as I often dont get home to 7pm or later.
Also people go to dealerships because they have the technical knowledge & back up that independants dont...I will take at least 2-3 phone calls per day from independents asking for free advice however due to loss of productive time you will find alot of dealers dont allow this anymore & simply request the car is brought in for inspection.

Salesmen.....will simply sell their sole to get a sell,promise you anything to get a deal however when your on a basic of around £3.60 per hour (if you dont sell you get pathetic wage!) with a family to feed it cant be easy.......oh my god i'm sticking up for salesmen:eek: there is of course the 70 hours a week you have to work!
Remember very few salesmen have technical knowledge of cars(those that do make better salesmen in my opinion)so dont slag them off because they dont know the torque setting for steering column pinch bolt...their job is to sell thats all.
When you buy a secondhand car remember that its secondhand.Dont moan about few scratches on it,tyres at 4-5mm & small holes in seat cloth...buy a new one if it bothers you that much the same as everyone else.

People that call dealers stealers(put it in the search box & see how many results you get) are generally found to be the ones that dont like to pay for anything or are pissed off because they have just had to pay a large repair bill due to their fault/got job done cheaper elsewhere but now its backfired & dealer has to sort problem out/abused service interval schedule.
Why oh f*cking why do people complain about paying £40-50 per hour when they are quite happy to pay plumbers/electricians/gas repairs £70+ per hour(I have recently been quoted £380 for 2 hours work by british gas...thats just labour price but am I constantly moaning about it?),happy to let solicitors charge them £40 for a letter saying "sorry there has been no response from the other party yet" (something wrong with a phone call here?) happy to pay £450+ paperwork for mortgage,happy to pay £120 for a ten minute house survey etc etc the list goes on.
If you can afford £9-10,000 for a car then you should have set aside a budget for servicing/maintence & unexpected repair bills.If you cant then why not buy a £7-8,000 car which you can maintain correctly,common sense really.

End of the day a good dealer will just survive,a poor dealer will fall by the wayside,but remember a few points before you slag a dealer...before you moan about the grumpy womanl on the reception desk think for a minute,how do you know its not because her husband has recently died or because her house has been repossed by the bank or her kid is sick or shes just simply having a bad day like happens to us all!
Another one is "£148 to fix a broken wire" you can f*ck off I aint paying you that".......fine,dont get your car back then! All the customer sees is large amount of money to fix damaged wire...what he(she)doesn't see is that he is aying for techs knowledge also the amount of wiring checks that had to be done and partial removal of dashboard to get to this wire.Myanswer to this is "well sir you & 3 other garages you went to before couldn't fix it so hows about I break the wire I the same place and you take it elsewhere again or try & find it yourself" the cheque is always wrote out immediately,and yes I have put the fault back on a car before because customer would not pay....& yes they did return.
So your alloys are scraped? are you 100% sure they weren't when you brought the car in? Recently had bloke said I scratched his alloys which was quite funny really cause the prick had his keys in his pocket - he forgot to leave them which was pointed out when he came back in shouting....nice try mate but not good enough (he came in to get wing mirror glass changed by the way) but dealers get this on a daily basis....ok I admit accidents do happen but how do you tell if claim is genuine or not? Now the customer is getting you sued & threatens you physically.....still want to run a Fiat dealership now?

Why do I come on this forum? Despite what alot of people think its not to defend dealers (although some get unfair abuse but some do deserve it!) but because I think Fiat are putting alot of efort into raising the Fiat name,getting away from the "my mate in the pub says Fiats are crap so they must be" attitude of alot of the public.I also think alot of techs get unfair abuse,there are some excellent technicians around & they deserve more credit than they get...which from the public is always none.
Also I like to dispell some of the myths about Fiats & of course help people if I can.I dont always get it right but hopefully put them in the right direction & lets not forget others on this forum itself which (as I have said over & over again) makes this a great forum to belong to....i'm happy to be a part of it & enjoy spending hours here everyday even if Ido get abit p*ssed off at some comments but hey no doubt some of you think same about me;)
End of the day we are here because of Fiat cars,our love of them & working on them...if dealers/techs/public gave bit more credit/support/respect to each another we can assure Fiats name will go on well into the future while others collapse as is already starting to happen around us!

Ian:)

p.s.you can wake up now:rolleyes:
 
T, the fact that you put so much time into your post shows you care about your role at the dealers. If I could I would take my Stilo to you every time. I take my hat off to you for keping the faith when so many of us (me included) have little good to say about the dealers.
 
Amazing post - The Forum is incredibly fortunate to have you.

.....And at the other end of the "Gas Gauge" scale lets all ignore and just skip right over Jug's worthless and offensive posts.
 
lots of good points there.

but you've got to remember T, there are always bent dealerships;)

my local reg vardy, haven't used them for any actual work, but managed (after a fair wait) to get some information regarding wiring and wiring looms, even photocopied me some info out of the book!
that alone wouldn't make me give them my car, unless they..........
 
Just read Ts' piece, ought to be compulsive reading for every one who goes on the site. Unfortunately a bad experience at a dealership often starts with the sales team who promise the earth and it is the techies who are left to pick up the pieces.

We all know there are good and bad dealerships out there and Fiat are probably no worse than any other volume marque but they are an easy target, especially for the media who like cheap laughs going on about rust and things falling off - any one bought a vauxhall or a peugeot recently? Anyway, it is up to sites like this to ensure that the general public get a fair view of the Fiat product range and that we as owners are honest and fair about the product we have bought. After all the message coming out from Stilo owners on the site is that the cars have annoying faults but are still liked and some are on their second or third so it can't be all that bad.
 
french bean said:
Just read Ts' piece, ought to be compulsive reading for every one who goes on the site. Unfortunately a bad experience at a dealership often starts with the sales team who promise the earth and it is the techies who are left to pick up the pieces.

We all know there are good and bad dealerships out there and Fiat are probably no worse than any other volume marque but they are an easy target, especially for the media who like cheap laughs going on about rust and things falling off - any one bought a vauxhall or a peugeot recently? Anyway, it is up to sites like this to ensure that the general public get a fair view of the Fiat product range and that we as owners are honest and fair about the product we have bought. After all the message coming out from Stilo owners on the site is that the cars have annoying faults but are still liked and some are on their second or third so it can't be all that bad.

you've hit the nail on the head in my opinion. fiat do have a poor (undeserved) reputation with joe public and as such when they buy one and the stitching on the steering wheel comes loose they go bananas and claim the whole car is s**t.(i was in a dealer and saw this happen - i had to laugh at the imagined site of a monster of a tech sitting down with a needle and thread):D
i do admit that i defend fiat alot (no i don't work for them)but i've had several different fiats and no real problems. dealers have been fine (lions of grays and various glynhopkins) and it has been a steep to service but i spent £9000 on my car and i'm not letting a back street spannermonkey near it. if i had spent £1500 on it then it would be a different story.
:)
 
Ransoman said:
I would love an independend fiat dealer around here.

I don't think my local has heard of customer service, It is like they don't even want sales. I come in last year looking for a punto sporting, i saw a speedgear on the forecourt but i thought i would ask the salesman inside if he had anything else.

me: Hello, do you have any punto sportings in stock.
Salesman: No.
.....
.....
.....
Me: well, do you know if any will be coming in soon?
Salesman: I don't know.......
......
Seriously, he was useless. No Offer "we have this one" or "we can source one from another branch" or anything. I just left.
How hard would it be to open an independant fiat dealer?
**********************************************************
Arnold Clark - Fiat/Alfa Aberdeen:

They've got all the pre-registered Grande Punto Sportings you could wish for in there at the moment ;) If you want to make a deal go in and ask to deal with Lisa - I'm sure you'll be satisfied.........
Plenty of FIAT/ALFA group cars on display the last time I was there (Thursday) place has had a minor re-organisation of stock layout.
Out of 10 - so far - I'd give them for service/warranty/general helpfulness a deserved 8.5 (y)
 
T14086 said:
Hope so....took me 2 hours to write it all out!

T' that post is indeed a thought provoking insight into what is what in the modern dealership... and as french bean said it should be compulsive reading for anybody on here. I have had dealings with Arnold Clarks, Oldbury (Birmingham) and Sunwin Fiat, Derby and found Sunwin especially to be good considering neither Stilo was purchased from them.

This forum, as a resource and the folks on here's willingness to help others, is one of the major factors in buying the JTD Stilo. The availability of insiders like yourself, HumanR, SchooweeNick etc. on here is appreciated! After checking SchooweeNick's post about the sping cup recall, checking my chassis number and phoning Sunwin to confirm my JTD was affected, they took it in the very next morning and it was sorted within 24 hours... now that is GOOD! (y)

Think the tendency to jump in with negative posts only is a shame... can honestly say FIATs still represent good value for money versus the competition and still find I'm happiest climing back behind the wheel of my Stilo after driving anything else :D
 
Back
Top