Toilet revelation/revolution?

Currently reading:
Toilet revelation/revolution?

Joined
Oct 1, 2017
Messages
7,348
Points
2,303
Location
Edinburgh Scotland
For all you DIY plumbers. Within the last couple of years I've renewed syphon units in all the family toilets, except those in my daughter's house down south, because the silly flimsy plastic foil syphon diaphragm valve had failed. Three of these were on close coupled cisterns, the other two on higher level cisterns with flush pipes but one of these was a real pain as the cistern was a concealed design being built into the bathroom wall vanity unit which meant the unit had to be partially dismantled before I could get at the cistern, which was a bit of a pain.

Even once you have access to the cistern this job is a bit of a drag because you first have to turn the water off and drain the cistern. With the higher level types you then have to remove the flush pipe and unscrew the syphon unit securing nut from underneath the cistern so the syphon unit can be withdrawn so you can either fit a new syphon unit (my preferred choice) or renew the diaphragm valve sheet. On the close coupled units, which the ones in my house are, the entire cistern has to be removed from the wall and toilet base unit to gain access to this nut.

None of this rates as "difficult" compared to fixing cars but there's always a bit of water to be spilt and some uncomfortable wriggling around to gain access to fixings on the close coupled units or, especially, the one installed in the vanity unit.

So when our downstairs loo:

P1090936.JPG

Which you can see is of the close coupled type - Natty colour eh? Very "trendy" some 40 years ago I can assure you - started being difficult to flush I was very pleased when our plumber (also now a friend) noticed this when he was servicing our boiler and offered to do it for me.

What I didn't know was that he was going to fit a Dudley 88 Duo Flush to rectify the problem. At first sight it looks just like any other syphon unit: https://www.screwfix.com/p/thomas-dudley-ltd-turbo-88-duo-flush-9-siphon-205mm/8461f and indeed to fit it the old unit:

P1090934.JPG

has to be removed and the Dudley unit fitted in it's place. The difference comes if you ever need to renew a diaphragm valve in the future because the new Dudley unit's syphon - the blue bit - can be split away from the delivery pipe - the white bit -and removed from the cistern simply by removing the yellow securing plug:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2sulSsMJl5c

This turns a nuisance job into a couple of minutes of relative pleasure! If I ever have to do another one I'll definitely be using one of these.

The old unit's diaphragm can be seen here and was in quite a sorry state:

P1090935.JPG

I have to say our plumber put me to shame regarding the time he took. I think I'd be doing pretty well to get the job completed in an hour. When I'd got a tarp spread out on the hall floor and he'd brought his tool bag in I asked him if he'd like a cuppaccino which he accepted. It's just a Lidl instant powder so I went into the kitchen, boiled the kettle and put the sachet into a cup. When the kettle had boiled I realized I hadn't asked him if he liked it sweetened. I went back into the hall and was astonished to see he already had the water isolated, supply and overflow pipes disconnected, the close couple flange disconnected and the cistern on it's side on the tarp in the hall where he was unscrewing the big syphon nut on the bottom! By the time I'd brought his cuppa through to him he had the new syphon installed and was lifting the cistern back onto the toilet base. He paused for a sip at the cuppaccino before reconnecting the pipes and tightening the close couple wing nuts. He was testing the flush less than half an hour after he'd walked through the front door!

Oh, and by the way, it does a clever half flush if you hold the flush lever down when flushing to save water. If you just work the lever and release it you get a full flush. I have to say it works very well indeed.

Here's the finished installation and you can just see the wee yellow plug that has to be levered out to allow the unit to be split.

P1090937.JPG

We've talked before about my car "hobby" and he said "come on then, let's see your workshop while I finish this coffee". He seemed quite surprised at my setup, I don't think he realized quite how seriously I'm into it. Anyway he knows I'm up for helping him out with keeping his wee van or car running if I can. He's a very practically minded chap and definitely the sort of chap who seems to approach the world with the same attitude I do, I'll be surprised if we don't become even better friends as time goes by. Best of all though was that he said he'd be embarrassed to take any more than £25 for doing the job. Mrs J actually handed the "readies" over while I was clearing up the tarp and old bits and pieces so I hope she included a "wee drink" but, regardless, I won't be charging him for any help he may ask for on his vehicles.

I'm sure some of you will know about these syphon units being the practical sort of people you are, but for those who don't I hope this has been useful.
 
Your water looks pretty 'peaty' Jock

Same as ours here in Wales :)

The Upper Thames where I lived until 50 has HARD water .. horrible limescale :(

When the immersion element died in my sons flat.. it took THREE HOURS to drain.. it was so full of scale

After the level dropped.. so I could remove the lower of the 2 elements.. I got to rake out 1 solid bucket of limescale..

Drained much better next time around :)
 
On an unrelated note...

I opened this thread slightly unsure as to what the contents might be.

Indeed.. :grin:

In our early days in this 150 year old place our Panda Driver managed a 'perfectstorm'

Blocked Pan + Failed flusher mechanism

Constant mains filling but with nowhere to go :eek:

Luckily it was summer..
Turns out a Council converted 'wetroom' isnt particularly watertight :rolleyes:
 
Indeed.. :grin:

In our early days in this 150 year old place our Panda Driver managed a 'perfectstorm'

Blocked Pan + Failed flusher mechanism

Constant mains filling but with nowhere to go :eek:

Luckily it was summer..
Turns out a Council converted 'wetroom' isnt particularly watertight :rolleyes:

Hopefully stopcock wasn't jammed open as well.

Toilet here appears cursed...3 new toilets in the last 10 years.

Just for fun the ground floor set up has very little incline between the pan and sewer exit at the back gate so I have a weekly job of slucing it with a couple of buckets. As although it does flow down hill a modern low flow toilet doesn't generate enough flow to move er 'solids' consistently. Would have been fine with an old 5 gallon flush, but not now, also it has a modern style cistern which I do not quite understand. Older ones you can look at them and figure it out..it's all quite small parts hidden in a tube and related to water pressure etc.
 
Last edited:
Your water looks pretty 'peaty' Jock

Same as ours here in Wales :)

The Upper Thames where I lived until 50 has HARD water .. horrible limescale :(

When the immersion element died in my sons flat.. it took THREE HOURS to drain.. it was so full of scale

After the level dropped.. so I could remove the lower of the 2 elements.. I got to rake out 1 solid bucket of limescale..

Drained much better next time around :)

Peaty? Not really so you'd notice just by looking at it Charlie but it does definitely leave brown stains behind long term and the header tank in the loft has a very fine brown silt in the bottom of it, like brown talcum powder when dry. I think a lot of our water comes from reservoirs in the southern uplands (border country) You probably need to go north of the Forth or north west to get the really peaty water. One of those schools I was incarcerated in as a youth was up in the highlands and I well remember the dark brown water in the freezing cold rivers we went swimming in - The cold seemed "refreshing" to me in those days, after all we had to take a cold plunge bath every morning after the morning run! It would definitely kill me now!

Here's an interesting wee article about Edinburgh's early attempts to secure a water supply - glad I wasn't around then! https://www.edinburghexpert.com/blog/castlehill-reservoir-and-edinburghs-water-supply

Yes I well remember the constant battle against limescale when we lived down in the south east. My daughter, as I've mentioned before, lives near Salisbury Wilts. Until a couple of years ago I don't think we'd ever visited when all the plumbing was working properly. The taps were stiff and often difficult to turn off. The thermostatic shower didn't self regulate - I could go on. However when they returned from their time in the States they had a water softener installed and the difference is remarkable.
 
Just for fun the ground floor set up has very little incline between the pan and sewer exit at the back gate so I have a weekly job of slucing it with a couple of buckets. As although it does flow down hill a modern low flow toilet doesn't generate enough flow to move er 'solids' consistently. Would have been fine with an old 5 gallon flush, but not now, also it has a modern style cistern which I do not quite understand. Older ones you can look at them and figure it out..it's all quite small parts hidden in a tube and related to water pressure etc.

The routing of the waste pipes in our house has always worried me. The main Scottish Water sewer pipe is in the street at the front of the house and our upstairs loos are at the back of the house where their pipes run together then straight down to a large diameter pipe which runs under the middle of the house and out to a manhole in the front garden then to the water company pipes in the road. The house has strip foundations (not a concrete raft foundation) so you could gain access to these pipes by taking up the flooring and digging big holes but the prospect would be terrifying and, I'm sure, cripplingly expensive. Seems to work though as all the houses on our estate are plumbed like this and I don't know of anyone having had a problem - so far anyway?

My youngest boy's extension had to be built over the top of the main sewer for the street. Before they could start construction Scottish Water insisted on the entire existing section of sewer on his property being dug up and replaced with new Ductile iron pipe - at his expense! This proved to be a pretty expensive exercise but was the only way permission to build would be granted. The installation is monolithic, It's such an overkill I don't think even a 500lb bomb would disturb it - which is just as well as it now lives under some pretty massive strip foundations and a concrete rafted floor. None of that is going to be disturbed easily! The pipes it replaced were very old and crumbly clay pipes of surprisingly small diameter. Our builder thought they had probably been the originals installed when these old miners cottages were built or certainly many years ago.

Regarding running water through the pipes to shift "solids" I'm in agreement with you so I'm really quite glad that this new syphon defaults to a full flush with you having to remember to keep the handle depressed as it flushes to get the partial flush. So a lot of the time I'd guess it'll be doing a full flush, not so environmentally correct but should keep my pipes clear?
 
Regarding running water through the pipes to shift "solids" I'm in agreement with you so I'm really quite glad that this new syphon defaults to a full flush with you having to remember to keep the handle depressed as it flushes to get the partial flush. So a lot of the time I'd guess it'll be doing a full flush, not so environmentally correct but should keep my pipes clear?

The only reason I do it regularly that it is significantly more pleasant than one clog occurring, it slowly backing up over a number of months and then having to spend an hour or so breaking up the resulting mess. To add to the fun it has Victorian interceptor trap at the back gate so if you dislodge a large clog then it just moves to block the rest of drainage.

Just chucking a 5 gallon bucket down it will generally be enough to clear anything left sitting in the pipe and take it off the property so it's just a case of a little bit of work prevents the possibility of an unpleasant afternoon.
 
Back
Top