just been brousing the wh smiths library and came accross the above autoexpress head to head,only had a brief read but the punto pipped the mini overall.one thing i did think was how brilliant the punto looked against the mini.the punto is a classy looking motor.everyone raved about the minis looks when it came out but i now think it starts look a bit boring.my mates got a mini and the inside of the car is really tacky the indicator storks look like kids toys,he's also had a lot of problems with the car,ive never known a car with so many rattles.and at the end of the day there not a cheap car to buy in the first place.for all the problems fiat have they know how to style cars.