To be honest, I don't have a problem with the Government's stance on this. After all, diesels do emit some nasty substances, allegedly....
The people I feel sorry for, are those folks who are going to second hand car dealers (or private sellers) and buying cheap diesels that should have Dpf's fitted, but probably, if they actually did some thorough checks prior to purchase, could find that the previous owner had the Dpf taken off or gutted. The second hand car dealer might not even know themselves, so they too could just as easily be duped. After all, if they buy a car from a private seller or from an auction and it has a valid MoT, they're not going to do much else to the car other than check it's legit/free from finance etc.
So Joe Bloggs goes to his local car trader (or private seller) and looks the seller in the eye and says, 'Is the Dpf still on this vehicle mate?' Seller looks him in the eye and says 'Dunno mate, how would I know that?' or just says, 'Course it has mate!' The fact is, virtually no one looking for a second hand diesel car post 2008, is going to ask that crucial question, they're just going to see a car, like the look of it, if the price is right, pay for it and drive away. Only later, sometime in the future, they have an MoT that detects' the absence of the Dpf, and suddenly, they're left with a pile of scrap because the cost of refitting a dpf is more than the car is worth. This isn't fantasy, it will happen, it's just a matter of 'when'.
Lots of cars that go through car auctions. Does anyone check if a diesel car is still fitted with a DPF and even if one 'appears' to still be there, if it's been gutted? Unless the Dpf is removed, no one will know. That car then ends up on a dealer forecourt or in private hands and no one is any the wiser. I'm surprised that some sort of written statement of fact concerning the presence and correct operation of a Dpf (for vehicles homulgated with such), isn't included during a diesel car sale, to protect both the trader and the buyer. As it stands, no one cares and no one is bothered because even the Government aren't doing anything.
Like your Golf H20MRV, my Saab tailpipes are super clean and I too can ooh err', shove my fingers up the pipe and it is clean, no soot whatsoever. Regular oil/filter changes, every 5000 miles, not a trace of nasty gunky thick black oil anywhere in or on my engine. It just annoys me when I'm stuck behind some nice diesel car chucking out piles of smoke on the motorway. You can often tell the ones that don't have a Dpf just by the amount of crap they're throwing out of the rear end.